Movement in Modernization

In “The Grocer and the Chief,” Lerner certainly weaves into his report his own views regarding modernization, notably a favoritism towards the spreading of Westernized practices. For Lerner, progress seems to represent a sort of movement, but one in which American or Western values dominate. Indeed, he highlights two forms of mobility–physical and societal–that seem to be at the core of progress for Lerner. Upon the advent of bus transportation, Lerner describes, “the villagers were getting out of their holes at last,” (51). Though a paraphrase of the Grocer’s previous comment, this statement implies Lerner’s view of the villagers’ acquisition of freedom: a release from a former position of not simply immobility, but also ignorance (similar to Plato’s cave). This distinctly contrasts the Chief telling Tosun that he “‘wouldn’t move a foot from [Balgat],'” (49) and the shepherd (who eventually moved villages) would rather kill himself then leave Balgat. As such, Lerner approaches his analysis of modernization with a familiar approach that it greatly benefits the many, while potentially harming the few. The second form of mobility is societal, which the Grocer evokes initially upon responding to what he would do as Turkey’s president. The ease with which he offers his answer–to “make roads for the villagers to come to towns to see the world,” (49)–reveals his thoughtfulness. He had taken to formulate an answer to a question that might be more commonly asked in democratic republics, where representatives listen to citizens voices. Similarly, the movement of agricultural to factory jobs results in a desire to gain capital, that villagers could later spend on refrigerators, tractors, trucks, and radios–the last of which giving them power that formerly only the Chief held.

Lerner’s evaluation of Turkey’s societal changes accentuates his biases as he promotes Westernized values, like various forms of mobility. While obvious to readers accessing such judgments, the next question to ask regards the extent to which Lerner himself is aware of his partiality. Having grown up in a country that praises its own “achievements,” I simply wonder to what extent it is possible to prevent my own biases from leaking through too.

107 thoughts on “Movement in Modernization

  1. Wenn Sie sich für die Schulungsprogramme zur Cisco 350-501 Zertifizierungsprüfung interessieren, können Sie im Internet teilweise die Demo zur Cisco 350-501 Zertifizierungsprüfung kostenlos als Probe herunterladen. Wir werden den Kunden einen einjährigen kostenlosen Update-Service bieten.

  2. It was one of the most beneficial pieces I’ve read in a while. Thanks to the Latest OGEA-103 exam cram materials, I got promoted and received a salary boost. It’s free now. Wishing you all a successful career advancement!

  3. Your article is exceptional, thank you for sharing it with us! I got promoted and received a raise thanks to the Exam 300-740 price. Now, I’m sharing it for free with everyone. Wishing you success in your career journeys!

  4. After reading this article, I feel that I’ve made progress in both thinking and actions. It’s nearly time for my Valid COF-C02 exam forum exam – wish me all the best!

  5. This is really an amazing article.Thanks a lot for sharing a piece of wonderful information keep it up and best of luck for your future article and posts.

  6. Truly a brilliant article, I’m so appreciative of your sharing. My career and salary took off thanks to the 300-410 latest exam vce questions—now I’m giving them to you for free!

  7. IBM C1000-182試験参考書を利用すれば、あなたは多くの時間を節約するだけでなく、いろいろな知識を身につけます。最も重要なのは、C1000-182認定試験資格証明書を取得できるということです。また、C1000-182試験参考書の合格率は高いので、C1000-182試験に落ちる必要がないです。

  8. The content is deep, and I’ve gained a lot of useful knowledge from it. The C-SIGVT-2506 new exam camp questions test led to my promotion and salary increase. Today, I’m giving it away for free to help you too!

  9. 在這個資訊時代,IT行業被很多人關注,但是在如今人才濟濟的社會裏任然比較缺乏IT人。很多公司都招聘IT人才,他們一般考察IT人才的能力會參考他們擁有的IT相關認證證書,所以擁有一些IT相關的認證證書是受很多公司歡迎的。但是這些認證證書也不是很容易就能拿到的。VMware 3V0-42.23 就是一個相當有難度的認證考試,雖然很多人報名參加VMware 3V0-42.23考試,但是通過率並不是很高。

  10. ITDumpsKR의SAP인증 C-C4H56I-34시험덤프공부가이드 마련은 현명한 선택입니다. SAP인증 C-C4H56I-34덤프구매로 시험패스가 쉬워지고 자격증 취득율이 제고되어 공을 많이 들이지 않고서도 성공을 달콤한 열매를 맛볼수 있습니다.

  11. 私たちSAPのC-THR86-2405トレントは、紙で学ぶだけでなく、携帯電話を使って学習できるように、さまざまなバージョンを特別に提案しました。 これにより、生徒が断片化した時間を利用できるようになります。 興味や習慣に応じて、PassTestのC-THR86-2405学習教材のバージョンを選択できます。 バリューパックを購入すると、3つのバージョンがすべて揃っており、価格は非常に優遇されており、すべての学習体験を楽しむことができます。 つまり、いつでもどこでもC-THR86-2405試験エンジンを勉強して、SAP Certified Associate – Implementation Consultant – SAP SuccessFactors Compensation試験に合格するのに役立ちます。

  12. Fast2test 是個很好的為 Fortinet FCP_FMG_AD-7.4 認證考試提供方便的網站。根據過去的考試練習題和答案的研究,它能有效的捕捉 Fortinet FCP_FMG_AD-7.4 認證考試試題內容。我們提供的 FCP_FMG_AD-7.4 考試練習題與真實的考試題有緊密的相似性。而且 FCP_FMG_AD-7.4 考題一直備受考生的稱贊,很多考生使用後,都知道出題高,讓他們順利過關。

  13. Thank you for the article; it was incredibly impressive and thought-provoking. Thanks to the QSBA2024 reliable test camp system, I got a promotion and a salary increase. Now, I’m making it free for everyone. Wishing you all a swift rise in your careers!

  14. The article is full of motivational insights, thank you for sharing! The Reliable SCS-C02 exam dumps questions exam was the key to my career success—now, I’m giving it away for free!

  15. I’m deeply grateful for your article, it really stood out. Free Latest study guide AZ-140 free download exam questions—best of luck to all exam candidates!

  16. 현재 많은 IT인사들이 같은 생각하고 잇습니다. 그것은 바로Amazon SAA-C03-KR인증시험자격증 취득으로 하여 IT업계의 아주 중요한 한걸음이라고 말입니다.그만큼Amazon SAA-C03-KR인증시험의 인기는 말 그대로 하늘을 찌르고 잇습니다,

  17. EMC D-XTR-DS-A-24 인증시험은 최근 가장 핫한 시험입니다. 인기가 높은 만큼EMC D-XTR-DS-A-24시험을 패스하여 취득하게 되는 자격증의 가치가 높습니다. 이렇게 좋은 자격증을 취득하는데 있어서의 필수과목인EMC D-XTR-DS-A-24시험을 어떻게 하면 한번에 패스할수 있을가요? 그 비결은 바로Itcertkr의 EMC D-XTR-DS-A-24덤프를 주문하여 가장 빠른 시일내에 덤프를 마스터하여 시험을 패스하는것입니다.

  18. Your article has truly left me speechless, thank you for sharing! Thanks to the Valid test MB-800 dumps pdf exam, I got promoted and earned a higher salary. Now, I’m giving it away for free today!

  19. Your article truly made me think, thank you for the fresh viewpoint. The Reliable PSP test dumps file exam helped me climb the career ladder and increase my salary, and today, I’m offering it to you for free!

  20. The logic in the article is very clear, and it has helped me understand many complex concepts. Here’s the CWT-101 Practice Mock test material for free. Best of luck in your exams!

  21. I felt like I walked away from that article with so much more knowledge. Free CPHQ Braindumps pdf to help you enhance your IT skills. Wishing you good luck!

  22. 還在為怎樣才能順利通過ISQI CTFL-Foundation 認證考試而苦惱嗎?還在苦苦等待ISQI CTFL-Foundation 認證考試的最新資料嗎?VCESoft研究出了最新的ISQI CTFL-Foundation 認證考試相關資料。想通過ISQI CTFL-Foundation 認證考試考試嗎?快將VCESoft的ISQI CTFL-Foundation認證考試的最新練習題及答案加入你的購物車吧!VCESoft已經在網站上為你免費提供部分ISQI CTFL-Foundation 認證考試的練習題和答案,你可以免費下載作為嘗試。相信你對我們的產品會很滿意的。利用它你可以很輕鬆地通過考試。我們承諾,如果你使用了VCESoft的最新的ISQI CTFL-Foundation 認證考試練習題和答案卻考試失敗,VCESoft將會全額退款給你。

  23. I’m absolutely amazed by your article, thank you for sharing it with me! Enhance your IT expertise and download Reliable test 5V0-63.23 sample online for free. Good luck to all!

  24. I’m left in complete awe by your article, thank you for sharing it! Free New test CT-AI questions explanations exam resources are available now—good luck!

  25. Bereiten Sie jetzt auf Splunk SPLK-1002 Prüfung? Wenn ja, sind Sie sicherlich ein Mensch mit Ambition. Wir Fast2test bemühen uns darum, den Menschen wie Ihnen zu helfen, Ihr Ziel zu erreichen. Die Simulierte-Prüfungssoftware der Splunk SPLK-1002 von uns enthält große Menge von Prüfungsaufgaben. Wenn Sie unsere Produkte gekauft haben, können Sie noch einjährige kostenlose Aktualisierung der Splunk SPLK-1002 genießen. Benutzen Sie unsere Software! Dann gibt es gar kein Problem bei des Bestehens der Splunk SPLK-1002 Prüfung!

  26. I sincerely thank you for sharing; the article is truly fantastic! I used the N10-009 latest cram materials to get promoted and earn more. Now, it’s available for free. Best of luck with your career!

  27. DumpTOP의SAP인증 C_HRHFC_2411시험덤프 공부가이드는 시장에서 가장 최신버전이자 최고의 품질을 지닌 시험공부자료입니다.IT업계에 종사중이라면 IT자격증취득을 승진이나 연봉협상의 수단으로 간주하고 자격증취득을 공을 들여야 합니다.회사다니면서 공부까지 하려면 몸이 힘들어 스트레스가 많이 쌓인다는것을 헤아려주는DumpTOP가 IT인증자격증에 도전하는데 성공하도록SAP인증 C_HRHFC_2411시험대비덤프를 제공해드립니다.

  28. 当社の製品で使用されているテストソフトウェアは、WindowsのTMMi-P_Syll2020学習教材に最適です。これにより、コンピューターで最高の学習スタイルを楽しむことができます。また、TMMi-P_Syll2020認定ガイドでは、最新の科学技術を使用して、権威ある研究材料ネットワーク学習の新しい要件を満たしています。従来の学習方法とは異なり、TMMi-P_Syll2020学習教材の大きな利点は、ユーザーが学習計画を柔軟に調整できることです。 TMMi-P_Syll2020テスト問題の新しいデザインが、ユーザーの学習をより面白く、カラフルにすることを願っています。

  29. C_S4CPR_2408試験問題は、シラバスの変更および理論と実践の最新の進展に応じて完全に改訂および更新されます。高品質の製品を提供するために、C_S4CPR_2408テストガイドを慎重に準備します。製品のすべての改訂と更新により、C_S4CPR_2408ガイドトレントに関する正確な情報を取得でき、大多数の学生が簡単に習得でき、重要な情報の内容を簡素化できます。当社の製品C_S4CPR_2408テストガイドは、より重要な情報をより少ない質問と回答で提供します。

  30. This article has given me a lot of space for reflection, and I’ve gained a lot. The Latest HP2-I73 dumps free download exam questions are now available for free. Good luck to everyone!

  31. Your article is truly stunning, thank you for sharing! This Accurate H12-111_V3.0 study material helped me achieve career growth with a promotion and salary raise. It’s free now for everyone. Wishing you success!

  32. Fast2test의 SAP인증 C-THR89-2405시험덤프는 실제시험의 기출문제와 예상문제를 묶어둔 공부자료로서 시험문제커버율이 상당히 높습니다.IT업계에 계속 종사하려는 IT인사들은 부단히 유력한 자격증을 취득하고 자신의 자리를 보존해야 합니다. Fast2test의 SAP인증 C-THR89-2405시험덤프로 어려운 SAP인증 C-THR89-2405시험을 쉽게 패스해보세요. IT자격증 취득이 여느때보다 여느일보다 쉬워져 자격증을 많이 따는 꿈을 실현해드립니다.

  33. This article is brilliant, thank you for this incredible share. I advanced in my career with this 312-38 online bootcamps, and now it’s free for everyone. May you all achieve your promotions soon!

  34. After reading this article, my understanding of the field has become more comprehensive. Valid C-SAC-2415 practice questions offers free access to a wealth of helpful material, supporting your learning goals.

  35. The article is very rich in content and has introduced me to many new ideas. I’m sharing the Reliable exam 300-540 questions explanations exam materials—best of luck to everyone!

  36. I definitely agree with what you’re saying here. There can be no doubt that Lerner has taken his own definition of progress and applied it to his research. The examples you provide support this claim, and the comparison between the ignorance of the prisoners in Plato’s cave and the ignorance of the people of Balgat is certainly applicable.

    In a sense, Lerner’s mindset very closely matches the imperialist mindset, as he praises the westernization that has killed traditional ideals in Balgat. He’s not necessarily wrong, but, for the sake of his credibility, he should report it rather than praise it.

    A note on your final paragraph: Lerner seems aware of his bias (as seen when he writes, “I decided that the Grocer was – and, to face right up to it, had been right from the start – my man” on page 48), though perhaps he should have made a greater effort to factor this knowledge into his research and conclusions.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *