Please Vote For Me: When do elections become undemocratic?

Posted on by

The Evergreen elementary school classroom election documented in “Please Vote For Me” shows us democracy in its most rudimentary form: candidates for a leadership position and a classroom full of voters with an equal say on the election outcome. Despite these basic conditions being met, the election nevertheless strays from the theoretical ideal of democracy.

Firstly, the students are poorly informed about democracy and its practices. At the beginning of the documentary, Xiaofei even asks what it means to vote. In an ideal democracy, the voters are well-informed about both the system and the candidates. Still, the election had the potential to provide a demonstration of what happens when democracy is introduced to an uninitiated group of voters. Unfortunately, the heavy involvement of the candidates’ parents means that their preconceptions of democracy influenced the election.

Additionally, Karl and Schmitter emphasize that truly democratic elections are fair, which the class monitor election was not. This is most evident in the bribery Luo Lei uses to collect votes. Despite seemingly being disliked by much of the class because of his strictness as class monitor and tendency for violence, he wins the election by a large margin because he takes the class on a field trip and hands out gifts at the end of his speech. Luo Lei’s history of violent behavior also likely implicitly threatened the class, who may very well have thought he would react violently to losing. This perceived lack of safety to vote as one pleases, coupled with Luo Lei’s blatant bribery, make the election unfair and thus undemocratic.

Interestingly, however, there are many similarities between the “democracy” on show at Evergreen elementary school and what we see in many supposedly democratic countries all over the world. Does this mean that we can’t consider these elections to be truly democratic? And if we do consider them democratic, does that make Luo Lei’s election democratic as well? Considering the corruption, unequal funding distribution among candidates, and/or even violent threats present in many (if not all) of today’s so-called democracies, can we say that any state has achieved anything near the ideal democracy?

 

98 thoughts on “Please Vote For Me: When do elections become undemocratic?”

  4. Excellent website with all of the information I wanted on this subject. Just wanted to tell you that you are doing great work, Keep it up!

  5. That article was incredibly rich in knowledge. This Latest test dumps SCS-C02 file helped me earn a promotion and raise. It’s now open to all for free. Wishing you success on your career growth!

  13. This article is truly remarkable, I’m grateful for your sharing. This is the Latest test ACD301 simulator fee exam that helped me achieve a promotion and pay raise. It’s free today—wishing you career success!

  21. Excellent website with all of the information I wanted on this subject. Just wanted to tell you that you are doing great work, Keep it up!

  26. 私たちは本当にお客様の貴重な意見をC-S4CPB-2508試験資料の作りの考慮に入れます。おそらく、君たちは私たちのC-S4CPB-2508試験資料について何も知らないかもしれません。でも、私たちのC-S4CPB-2508試験資料のデモをダウンロードしてみると、全部わかるようになります。そのデモはC-S4CPB-2508試験資料の一部を含めています。

  36. Pass4Test bietet verschiedene Schulungsunterlagen und Ressourcen zur Vorbereitung der SAP C_THINK1_02 Prüfung. Es umfasst Kurse, Praxis-Test, Online Test Engine und einen Teil kostenloser PDF-Download.

  38. I’m truly thankful for your article, it really stood out. The Valid C-THR84-2405 exam camp helped me achieve a promotion and salary increase. Now, it’s free for everyone. Best wishes for your professional success!

  39. 成功することが大変難しいと思っていますか。IT認定試験に合格するのは難しいと思いますか。今SalesforceのCRT-403認定試験のためにため息をつくのでしょうか。実際にはそれは全く不要です。IT認定試験はあなたの思い通りに神秘的なものではありません。我々は適当なツールを使用して成功することができます。適切なツールを選択する限り、成功することは正に朝飯前のことです。どんなツールが最高なのかを知りたいですか。いま教えてあげます。GoShikenのCRT-403問題集が最高のツールです。この問題集には試験の優秀な過去問が集められ、しかも最新のシラバスに従って出題される可能性がある新しい問題も追加しました。これはあなたが一回で試験に合格することを保証できる問題集です。

  40. I’m so impressed by your article, thank you for your amazing share! Don’t miss your chance to get the free MB-700 exam pattern questions—the key to promotion and salary growth!

  43. After reading this article, I have a more in-depth understanding of the related topics. Here are the 700-695 reliable test vce questions for free—your key to career advancement!

  44. PassTIP의 Cisco 인증 200-301-KR시험덤프공부자료는 pdf버전과 소프트웨어버전 두가지 버전으로 제공되는데 Cisco 인증 200-301-KR실제시험예상문제가 포함되어있습니다.덤프의 예상문제는 Cisco 인증 200-301-KR실제시험의 대부분 문제를 적중하여 높은 통과율과 점유율을 자랑하고 있습니다. PassTIP의 Cisco 인증 200-301-KR덤프를 선택하시면 IT자격증 취득에 더할것 없는 힘이 될것입니다.

  45. NewDumps提供的產品有很高的品質和可靠性。你可以先在網上免費下載部分NewDumps提供的關於SAP C-TS414-2023 認證考試的練習題和答案作為嘗試。在你使用之後，相信你會很滿意我們的產品的。這麼好的一個能幫助你順利通過考試的產品，你還在猶豫什麼，快將NewDumps的產品加入您的購物車吧。

  48. 我々Topexamは一番信頼できるIT試験資料販売サイトになれるために、弊社はお客様に最完備かつ最新版のJN0-252問題集を提供して努力します。我々の問題集によって、ほとんどの受験生は大方の人から見る大変なJuniper JN0-252試験にうまく合格しました。この成功データはJN0-252試験に準備する皆様にTopexamのJN0-252問題集を勧める根拠とします。もしあなたは残念的にJN0-252試験に失敗したら、全額で返金することを承諾します。すべてのことはあなたの安心的に試験に準備できるのためのです。

  49. Zertpruefung bietet verschiedene Schulungsunterlagen und Ressourcen zur Vorbereitung der HP HP2-I73 Prüfung. Es umfasst Kurse, Praxis-Test, Online Test Engine und einen Teil kostenloser PDF-Download.

  50. That was a truly transformative read. The 1Z0-1041-21 Practice Mock exam that helped me get promoted and earn a salary raise is available for you today at no charge. Hope you reach your career targets soon!

  51. Itcertkr의Huawei H12-811_V1.0시험자료의 문제와 답이 실제시험의 문제와 답과 아주 비슷합니다. 우리의 짧은 학습가이드로 빠른 시일 내에 관련지식을 터득하여 응시준비를 하게 합니다. 우리는 우리의Huawei H12-811_V1.0인증시험덤프로 시험패스를 보장합니다.

  57. Reading this article, I have gained a completely new understanding of the issue. I owe my career success to the Valid SK0-005 test topics test, and now I’m sharing it with you free of charge!

  59. I’m truly grateful for your article, it really stayed in my mind. The New COBIT5 exam registration test was my key to career success. Get it for free today and start advancing your career!

  60. Thank you for sharing this truly inspiring piece of writing! I achieved my promotion and salary raise with this CGEIT exam dumps free. Now it’s free for all. Hope you get promoted soon!

  62. I’m in awe of this article, thank you for sharing it with us! The Reliable C-THR89-2405 test camp sheet was the key to my promotion and raise. Now it’s free to everyone. Wishing you all a successful career boost!

  63. 効率的なHealth-Cloud-Accredited-Professional学習教材を使用すれば、専門的な資格試験に合格した製品を使用しなかった場合に必要な時間の半分を費やすだけで済みます。このようにして、旅行、パーティー、さらに別の試験の準備をする時間が増えます。あなたのためのHealth-Cloud-Accredited-Professionalトレーニングトレントの利点は、お金で測られるにはほど遠いです。一流の専門家チーム、高度な学習コンセプト、完全な学習モデルがあります。時間を節約し、Health-Cloud-Accredited-Professional学習教材であなたの成功を保証することは、私たちにとって最大の見返りです

  67. IT業界の中でたくさんの野心的な専門家がいって、IT業界の中でより一層頂上まで一歩更に近く立ちたくてMicrosoftのDP-900J試験に参加して認可を得たくて、Microsoft のDP-900J試験が難度の高いので合格率も比較的低いです。MicrosoftのDP-900J試験を申し込むのは賢明な選択で今のは競争の激しいIT業界では、絶えず自分を高めるべきです。しかし多くの選択肢があるので君はきっと悩んでいましょう。

  69. I’m left in complete awe by your article, thank you for sharing it! The 300-300 valid exam sample online questions helped me secure a raise and promotion, and today, I’m sharing them for free!

  71. Truly outstanding, thank you for sharing this brilliant article. Here’s the New PL-100 exam simulator fee test that helped me get promoted and raise my salary. It’s free today—hope it helps you with your career goals!

  72. Your article truly left me in awe, thank you for sharing! I’m sharing the 1z1-902 Answers Real Questions questions that helped me achieve my promotion and raise—get them for free today!

  75. I’m deeply thankful for your article, it really stuck with me. Here’s the 1Z0-1050-24 learning mode test that played a part in my promotion and salary increase, and it’s free for you today! Wishing you all the best in your career!

  77. PDFExamDumps的Marketing-Cloud-Email-Specialist考古題是一個保證你一次及格的資料。這個考古題的命中率非常高，所以你只需要用這一個資料就可以通過考試。如果不相信就先試用一下。因為如果考試不合格的話PDFExamDumps會全額退款，所以你不會有任何損失。用過以後你就知道Marketing-Cloud-Email-Specialist考古題的品質了，因此趕緊試一下吧。問題有提供demo，點擊PDFExamDumps的網站去下載吧。

  82. Your article really stood out, I’m so grateful for it. These D-CSF-SC-23 reliable test collection materials questions helped me climb the career ladder and increase my earnings, and now I’m sharing them with you for free!

  88. あなたのIT能力が権威的に認められるのがほしいですか。EMCのDEA-7TT2試験に合格するのは最良の方法の一です。我々JPTestKingの開発するEMCのDEA-7TT2ソフトはあなたに一番速い速度でEMCのDEA-7TT2試験のコツを把握させることができます。豊富な資料、便利なページ構成と購入した一年間の無料更新はあなたにEMCのDEA-7TT2試験に合格させる最高の支持です。

  94. I’m really inspired after reading this article, thanks so much for sharing! Sharpen your IT knowledge with free Passing CFCS score feedback. Best of luck to you!

  98. I definitely found myself coming to similar inquiries as I thought about the performance of democracy in this third grade classroom. The lack of an ideal democracy certainly is two-fold. Indeed, the students lack the knowledge needed to understand the system of government, and from there, they are unable to hold the elected officials accountable for any actions that stray from democracy. Does this reflect democracies we see across the globe? It is not rare for citizens to lack a complete understanding of their state of government, especially when it offers them rights (ie. non-authoritarian). Perhaps, in some sense, these complexities cause citizens to grow more less enthusiastic of democratic forms of government, as Mounk observes in his article. I believe however, that while democracy in its ideal form may be unattainable, it is still worth striving for it via education, the latter being a mechanism to instill a sense of empowerment in a country’s citizens.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *