Against Gatto: Modern Schooling is Flawed, but Necessary

Posted on by

While I agree with many of Gatto’s points, I believe that parts of this article are far-fetched. He starts out by addressing how both students and teachers alike operate within institutions where “boredom and childishness were the natural state of affairs,” and I agree that this is a widespread problem that plagues our nation’s school system today. I personally have had teachers that have been fired over departing from standard curriculums and instead imposing more intellectual discussions, class debates, and life lessons, and I have grown up in a metro area where many of the schools are struggling to find students and teachers alike that express a passion for education.

However, I view these widespread problems as flaws within our education system that we need to work to change, and not valid reason to throw schooling out the window. While Gatto’s argument that formal schooling is unnecessary to achieve success is certainly valid, most of the people whom he references – Mark Twain, Thomas Edison, and Margaret Mead are examples – he fails to account for the vast changes our society has undergone since they were alive. Throughout the latter half of the twentieth century and the twenty-first century, our country has undergone rapid digitalization, and with that a skill biased technological change that greatly increased the demand for skilled workers and decreased the demand for unskilled workers. While our education system is far from perfect, it is still the best way to ensure success and stability for millions of Americans.

Lastly, many of the “purposes” of modern schooling that Gatto draws upon from Principles of Secondary Education are, quite frankly, ridiculous. Most notably, the “selective function” that Gatto elaborates on, and while it is disturbing I completely reject the idea that a purpose of modern schooling is to “help things along by consciously attempting to improve breeding stock.” While I fully acknowledge the fact that students who do well in school are more likely to attend more selective colleges and universities, claiming that schools serve as a way of enforcing natural selection is nearly comical and, as can be seen throughout our country, is not even remotely true. While I agree with Gatto entirely that our school system is flawed, I believe that there are ways to combat the problem at hand and create a more inclusive, intellectual education system, rather than plainly advocating against the need for school as a whole.

102 thoughts on “Against Gatto: Modern Schooling is Flawed, but Necessary”

  8. The content of this article has been very helpful to my personal growth. Here’s the Study 312-50v13 demo exam that helped me achieve career growth with a promotion and raise. It’s free for everyone today—best wishes in your career!

  10. SalesforceのSalesforce-MuleSoft-Associate認証試験はIT業界にとても重要な地位があることがみんなが、たやすくその証本をとることはではありません。いまの市場にとてもよい問題集が探すことは難しいです。MogiExamは認定で優秀なIT資料のウエブサイトで、ここでSalesforce Salesforce-MuleSoft-Associate認定試験「Salesforce Certified MuleSoft Associate」の先輩の経験と暦年の試験の材料を見つけることができるとともに部分の最新の試験の題目と詳しい回答を無料にダウンロードこともできますよ。

  13. I’m really enjoying this content, definitely hitting like. Sharing the C_S4CPB_2508 dumps cost test that led to my promotion and raise, now free to all. Best wishes in your pursuit of career success!

  16. I simply wanted to write down a quick word to say thanks to you for those wonderful tips and hints you are showing on this site.

  17. IT業種で仕事している皆さんが現在最も受験したい認定試験はOracleの認定試験のようですね。広く認証されている認証試験として、Oracleの試験はますます人気があるようになっています。その中で、1Z0-1072-24-JPN認定試験が最も重要な一つです。この試験の認定資格はあなたが高い技能を身につけていることも証明できます。しかし、試験の大切さと同じ、この試験も非常に難しいです。試験に合格するのは少し大変ですが、心配しないでくださいよ。Pass4Testは1Z0-1072-24-JPN認定試験に合格することを助けてあげますから。

  18. This content is fantastic; I’m hitting like without a second thought. The Test 300-435 quiz exam questions are available for free. Wishing you the best in your exams!

  25. I felt deeply enriched by that article. This Valid test dumps C_S4TM_2023 questions helped me earn a promotion and raise. It’s now open to all for free. Wishing you success on your career growth!

  26. KoreaDumps의 경험이 풍부한 IT전문가들이 연구제작해낸 Salesforce인증 PDI덤프는 시험패스율이 100%에 가까워 시험의 첫번째 도전에서 한방에 시험패스하도록 도와드립니다. Salesforce인증 PDI덤프는Salesforce인증 PDI최신 실제시험문제의 모든 시험문제를 커버하고 있어 덤프에 있는 내용만 공부하시면 아무런 걱정없이 시험에 도전할수 있습니다.

  31. PAL-I試験に合格すると多くのメリットが得られることは誰もが知っていますが、Scrumすべての受験者がそれを達成するのは容易ではありません。 PAL-Iガイド急流は、すべての受験者が試験に合格するのを支援することを目的としたツールです。 私たちの試験資料は、コンピュータと人の量に制限なしでインストールおよびダウンロードできます。 弊社が提供するPAL-I学習資料が有用であり、テストに合格するのに役立つことを保証します。 製品を購入すると、便利な方法を使用して、いつでもどこでもPAL-I試験トレントを学習できます。 そのため、購入の前後に安心して、PAL-I学習教材にウイルスがないことを信頼してください。 Professional Agile Leadership (PAL I)当社の製品Topexamに慣れるために、PAL-I学習教材の機能と利点を次のようにリストします。

  33. Mit Zertpruefung können Sie sich nicht nur wertvolle Zeit ersparen, sondern auch sich ganz beruhigt auf die Prüfung vorbereiten und sie erfolgreich bestehen. Zertpruefung hat eine gute Zuverlässigkeit und ein hohes Ansehen in der IT-Branche. Sie können kostenlos einen Teil der von Zertpruefung gebotene ISC CISSP-German Prüfungsfragen und Antworten als Probe herunterladen, um die Zuverlässigkeit unserer Produkte zu testen. Sie werden sicher mit unserern Produkten sehr zufrieden sein. Ich habe Vertrauen in unsere Produkte und glaube, dass die von Zertpruefung bietenden Prüfungsfragen und Antworten zu ISC CISSP-German Zertifizierung bald Ihre beste Wahl sein würden. Und sie würden sicher die CISSP-German Zertifizierungsprüfung erfolgreich abschließen. Es ist ratsam, Zertpruefung zu wählen. Zertpruefung würde Ihnen die zufriedenen Produkte bieten.

  42. This article is deep, and I’ve learned many valuable experiences from it. The Reliable exam C_THR95_2405 objectives pdf helped me secure a promotion and salary raise. Now it’s free to all. Best wishes for your career advancements!

  45. The content is top-notch, definitely deserving of a like. This is the C-SEN-2305 updated demo exam that helped me get ahead with a promotion and pay raise. It’s free for everyone today. Wishing you all career success!

  46. That piece really enriched my understanding. The CFE valid dumps files helped me with a promotion and raise. Now it’s free to everyone. May your career progression be swift!

  47. This article is refreshing, and it’s really worth reading. The 5V0-31.23 latest exam topics exam helped me climb the career ladder and increase my salary, and today, I’m offering it to you for free!

  48. Thank you so much for your article, it’s something I’ll remember. New MB-280 exam lab questions offers great content that I hope helps you, and it’s entirely free.

  49. CISSP-ISSEPクイズトレントブースト3バージョンには、PDFバージョン、PCバージョン、アプリオンラインバージョンが含まれます。バージョンが異なると、機能や使用方法が異なります。たとえば、PDFバージョンは、CISSP-ISSEP試験トレントをダウンロードして印刷するのに便利で、学習を閲覧するのに簡単で適しています。また、CISSP-ISSEPクイズトレントのPCバージョンは、実際の試験のシナリオを刺激することができ、Windowsオペレーティングシステムで停止します。ISC独自のCISSP-ISSEP – Information Systems Security Engineering Professional試験刺激テストのスコアと、CISSP-ISSEP試験トレントをマスターしたかどうかをいつでもテストできます。

  50. This article has truly inspired me, thank you for sharing! I used the PREX-1060A reliable test camp materials set to achieve my promotion and pay raise. It’s now free for everyone. Best of luck in your promotions!

  51. 当社SASInstituteのA00-282ガイド急流は、過去の試験論文と業界での人気の傾向に基づいて、厳密な分析と要約を行っており、改訂および更新されています。 A00-282試験問題により、洗練された概念が簡素化されました。このソフトウェアは、さまざまな自己学習および自己評価機能を強化して、学習結果を確認します。 A00-282テストトレントのソフトウェアは、統計レポート機能を提供し、学生が脆弱なリンクを見つけて対処するのに役立ちます。 A00-282試験問題のこのバージョンを使用すると、試験に簡単に合格することができます。

  53. Instant like; this content is too good. I’m giving you access to the C-C4H62-2408 test sample questions test that helped me achieve a promotion and salary raise. It’s free today—wishing you success!

  54. Your article has made a lasting impression, thank you for it. Free access to PSK-I reliable braindumps book’s extensive content is offered, with the aim of supporting you.

  55. IT業種を選んだあなたは現状に自己満足することはきっとないですね。現在、どの業種の競争でも激しくなっていて、IT業種も例外ないですから、目標を立ったら勇気を持って目標を達成するために頑張るべきです。その中で、AmazonのSAP-C02試験に受かることも競争力があるモードです。この試験に合格したら、あなたのITキャリアには明るい未来があるようになります。あなたを助けるために、我々のPass4Testは真実かつ正確なトレーニング資料を提供します。Pass4Testを利用したら、あなたはきっと自分の理想を実現することができます。

  63. This article is very content-rich and has helped me enhance my understanding. The Latest test D-PM-MN-23 discount voucher test was vital in advancing my career and income—today, it’s yours for free!

  68. 多年以來，Fast2test一直致力於為廣大參加IT認證考試的考生們提供最優秀並且最值得信賴的參考資料。關於IT認證考試的出題，Fast2test有著豐富的經驗。而且，Fast2test已經幫助過無數的考生，並得到了大家的信賴和表揚。所以，不要懷疑Fast2test的220-1101考古題的品質了。這絕對是一個可以保證你通過220-1101考試的資料。Fast2test向你保證考不過就全額退款。有了這個保證，你完全沒有必要再猶豫到底要不要買這個考古題了。错过了它将是你很大的损失。

  71. Es ist uns allen bekannt, dass IT-Branche eine neue Branche und auch eine Kette ist, die die wirtschaftliche Entwicklung fördert. So ist ihre Position nicht zu ignorieren. Die Avaya 61451T IT-Zertifizierung ist eine Methode für den Wettbewerb. Durch die Avaya 61451T Zertifizierung werden Sie sich in allen Aspekten verbessern. Aber es ist nicht so einfach, die Prüfung zu bestehen. So empfehle ich Ihnen unsere originale Fragen. Wenn Sie die Schulungsressourcen wählen, ist ZertSoft die erste Wahl. Seine Erfolgsquote beträgt 100%. Und Sie können die Avaya 61451T Prüfung sicher bestehen.

  72. 所有的SAP職員都知道，P-C4H34-2411認證考試的資格是不容易拿到的。但是，參加P-C4H34-2411認證考試獲得資格又是提升自己能力以及更好地證明自己的價值的途徑，所以不得不選擇。那麼，難道沒有一個簡單的方法可以讓大家更容易地通過SAP認證考試嗎？當然有了。VCESoft的考古題就是一個最好的方法。VCESoft有你需要的所有資料，絕對可以滿足你的要求。你可以到VCESoft的网站了解更多的信息，找到你想要的考试资料。

  73. Your article has left me speechless, thank you for sharing it! The Latest CIS-CSM braindumps files resource is packed with content and made available for free to help you.

  76. I’m so thankful for your article, it was really eye-catching. The Reliable C-LIXEA-2404 test experience test was my key to career success. Get it for free today and start advancing your career!

  78. After reading this article, I have a more thorough understanding of the related topics. I’m sharing the Training C_TS462_2023 for exam questions that made my promotion and raise possible—get them for free!

  89. I’m utterly amazed by your article, thank you for sharing it! The aPHRi valid exam camp free helped me secure a promotion and salary raise. Now it’s free to all. Best wishes for your career advancements!

  90. I appreciate your article, it really gave me a new perspective. The Valid exam collection CSQE file helped me land a promotion and salary increase. It’s free for everyone now. Best of luck with your promotions!

  91. I’m so grateful for your article, it truly stayed with me. This RhMSUS sure pass helped me get promoted and enjoy a salary raise. Now it’s available to you for free. Hope you all advance soon!

  99. I deeply appreciate your share, this article is simply astonishing! The material in CISM exam book is extensive and offered freely to support your learning goals.

  102. While aspects of Gatto’s claims may be far-fetched, I believe that they have basis in reality. Because of the digitalization in the workforce you describe, we may have less demand for “unskilled workers” (I assume this refers to, for example, workers in factories whose jobs are now performed either by machines or workers in other countries). However, the technology industry in some ways makes modern-day examples of figures such as the cited Mark Twain, Thomas Edison, and Margaret Mead possible – think Bill Gates, who dropped out of Harvard to pursue a path independent of traditional education – because of the new emphasis on the creativity and entrepreneurship of young minds.

    The claim about natural selection also seems somewhat realistic when considering the breeding pools of people who end up interacting with each other. I am always struck by the fact that at any college (especially high-level institutions such as Williams), I know multiple people in common with almost any student I meet. It’s only such a “small world” because the top 1% (or whatever it may be) of society tends to interact exclusively with themselves. This absolutely has an impact on who ends up having kids together, serving a “selective” function maintained by issues with college access, etc.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *