Lerner’s description of Balgat changing over time, as well as the conclusions he draws about the “positive” effects that modernity seems to have had on the village, suggests Lerner’s belief in a universal definition of progress. For Lerner, “progress” is inextricably tied to technological improvements, and a movement towards industrialization. When he returns to Balgat, he is excited by the emergence of public transportation, and more technical jobs, which have replaced farming. This replacement of farming, however, has noticeable consequences on villagers’ employment. Lerner does not explore the possibility that the majority of people in Balgat may have been content without these changes. However, he also offers evidence of many villagers’ willingness to accept change. The last Muhtar says that he is “happy” to have seen Balgat “end its history in this way that we are going” (55). The Muhtar, in addition to the Chief and his two sons, provide examples of people who seem to have accepted their position of passivity in a world changing around them. The Chief in particular expresses great resiliency in the face of modernization and hope for his posterity. Nonetheless, Lerner’s selection of these details, personal accounts, and reactions all point to an effort to paint modernization in a universally positive light. “Progress”, for Lerner, is a departure from manual labor, and lack of technology, and an embrace of technological “improvement.”
Introduction to Comparative Politics: Nationalism, Ideology, and State Power
Professor Shervin Malekzadeh
I’m so appreciative of your article, it really made an impression. The Latest CISM test voucher questions are shared for free. Good luck on your exams!
Your article is brilliant beyond measure, thank you for sharing! The free Reliable study questions 1Z0-931-24 sheet test materials are available for all. Good luck!
100% Garantie Salesforce Certified Nonprofit Cloud Consultant Exam Prüfungserfolg, Wenn Sie Zertpruefung Nonprofit-Cloud-Consultant Prüfung wählen Salesforce Zertpruefung Test Engine ist das perfekte Werkzeug, um auf die Zertifizierungsprüfung vorbereiten. Erfolg kommt einfach, wenn Sie bereiten mit Hilfe von Original bis zu Salesforce Certified Nonprofit Cloud Consultant Exam Produkte mit Zertpruefung Datum. Wie ein seltener Fall, wenn Sie es versäumen, diese Prüfung geben wir Ihnen eine volle Rückerstattung Ihres Einkaufs passieren.
This article made me realize many details I hadn’t paid attention to before. The Cost-effective Marketing-Cloud-Developer certification study materials are available for free—good luck!
What a motivating article, thanks for sharing it with us! This New C_THR96_2405 exam study guide helped me get promoted and receive a raise. Now I’m offering it for free. Wishing you all success in your career paths!
Your article has made a lasting impression, thank you! D-PVM-OE-23 latest real test answers has fantastic materials, and it’s offered to you free of charge.
I think you raise a really interesting point. Lerner does mention that agricultural jobs are virtually nonexistent but then he never goes into detail about it. It seems his piece would have had a much better balance if he had written about some of the losers in Balgat’s development. It is a very idealized article that ignores many of the “losers” in modernity.