The Ever-Expanding Scope of Gessen’s Analysis

Posted on by

In Masha Gessen’s “The Dying Russians,” she effectively synthesizes several researchers and statisticians’ claims about the situation, however she seems far too interested in identifying one overarching truth or theory that can apply to all Russian depopulation over the course of several decades. She starts with a reasonable question of why people were dying in 1993 in Russia, but as her essay continues, she expands the scope of her theorizing to several periods of Russian depopulation, even abruptly comparing Russia to other post-Soviet states in her last paragraph.

While there may be a “truth” that lies beyond the grasp of social science, as we have learned, it is unrealistic to try and discover this truth right away. While I think we should ultimately strive to understand these truths, to even get close, it takes a lot more research than Gessen references before we can even try to make a guess at a reason behind all the deaths in Russia. While essays we have read so far—Havel, Wedeen, Crick, etc.—have built off of each other, referencing others’ work and creating a conversation through their writing, the researchers Geffen references seem to exist entirely independently of each other. Perhaps this is because this is such a recent and contemporary issue, but it does not seem that Parsons, Eberstadt, and others are building off of each other’s work. I believe social science works best and is most effective when we can examining a problem from multiple perspectives, using interviews, statistics, and whatever information we may have to look a problem, while limiting the scope of our theorizing, as suggested by Ziblatt. By doing this, we can potentially figure out why Russians are dying or have died during a certain period of time, and then try to apply our discovers to other periods of time, rather than making silly generalizations that Russia is dying of a “broken heart.”

42 thoughts on “The Ever-Expanding Scope of Gessen’s Analysis”

  1. 通過很多已經使用NewDumps的些針對IT認證考試培訓資料的考生的回饋，證明了使用我們的NewDumps的產品通過It認證考試是很容易的。NewDumps最近研究出來了關於熱門的CIMA CIMAPRO19-CS3-1 認證考試的培訓方案，包括一些針對性的測試題，可以幫助你鞏固知識，讓你為CIMA CIMAPRO19-CS3-1 認證考試做好充分的準備。

  2. I sincerely appreciate your article; it really left a deep impression on me! This Exam C_ARSOR_2404 reference helped me move up in my career and get a raise. Now it’s free to all. Wishing you success in your career journey!

  3. I sincerely thank you for sharing this heart-shaking article! The Reliable GB0-372 test materials resource is full of valuable information and is free for everyone. We hope it’s useful to you.

  7. I’m really inspired by this article, thank you for sharing it! This HQT-4420 valid exam questions pdf helped me get a promotion and salary hike. I’m now making it available for free. Wishing you all career success!

  8. 初心者にとって、H13-311_V3.5試験に合格するのはそんなに難しいことですか？実は、我々JPNTestのH13-311_V3.5問題集を選んで利用し、お客様は力の限りまで勉強して、合格しやすいです。万が一パースしない場合には、弊社は全額返金を承諾いたします。返金を願うのに対して、お客様はH13-311_V3.5に合格しない成績書を弊社に送付して、弊社は確認の後、支払い金額を全部返済します。

  9. No second thoughts, just hitting the like button for this great content. The Reliable exam COBIT5 collection sheet material is outstanding, and it’s free for you to use.

  12. すべての働く人は、MS-721がこの分野で支配的な人物であり、また彼らのキャリアに役立つことを知っています。 MS-721信頼性の高い試験ブートキャンプが試験に合格し、資格証明書を取得するのに役立つ場合、より良いキャリア、より良い人生を得ることができます。 私たちの研究MS-721ガイド資料は、最新のMS-721テストの質問と回答のほとんどを網羅しています。 確かにこの分野で何か違うことをしようと決心しているなら、役に立つ認定はあなたのキャリアの足がかりになるでしょう。

  14. The article is very content-rich and has given me many practical insights. Upgrade your IT skills with free 302 valid test passing score. Best wishes for your success!

  15. 你肯定聽說過VCESoft的NSE7_PBC-7.2考古題吧？但是，你用過嗎？我們經常會聽到“VCESoft的考古題真是好資料，多虧了它我才通過了考試”這樣的話。VCESoft從使用過考古題的人們那裏得到了很多的好評。這是因為它確實能幫助考生們節省很多時間，並保證大家順利通過考試。

  16. I’m so grateful for your article, it truly grabbed my attention. This Testcollection CTAL-TTA helped me get promoted and earn more. Now, it’s free for everyone. Wishing you all success in reaching your promotions!

  21. I truly appreciate your article, it really left a deep impression on me. Thanks to the FCP_FAZ_AD-7.4 reliable test camp file, I achieved a promotion and salary raise. Now, I’m sharing it for free with everyone. Best of luck with your career advancements!

  23. 그렇게 많은 IT인증덤프공부자료를 제공하는 사이트중PassTIP의 인지도가 제일 높은 원인은 무엇일가요?그건PassTIP의 제품이 가장 좋다는 것을 의미합니다. PassTIP에서 제공해드리는 EMC인증 D-CIS-FN-23덤프공부자료는EMC인증 D-CIS-FN-23실제시험문제에 초점을 맞추어 시험커버율이 거의 100%입니다. 이 덤프만 공부하시면EMC인증 D-CIS-FN-23시험패스에 자신을 느끼게 됩니다.

  24. I’m deeply inspired by this article, thank you for sharing it! Sharing the New 1Y0-204 exam notes exam that helped me with my career advancement and raise—it’s free for all today. Best of luck on your professional journey!

  27. JPNTestのTA-003-P問題集は的中率が100％に達することができます。この問題集は利用したそれぞれの人を順調に試験に合格させます。もちろん、これはあなたが全然努力する必要がないという意味ではありません。あなたがする必要があるのは、問題集に出るすべての問題を真剣に勉強することです。この方法だけで、試験を受けるときに簡単に扱うことができます。いかがですか。JPNTestの問題集はあなたを試験の準備する時間を大量に節約させることができます。これはあなたがTA-003-P認定試験に合格できる保障です。この資料が欲しいですか。では、早くJPNTestのサイトをクリックして問題集を購入しましょう。それに、購入する前に、資料のサンプルを試すことができます。そうすれば、あなたは自分自身で問題集の品質が良いかどうかを確かめることができます。

  28. Wie andere weltberühmte Zertifizierungen wird die Salesforce-AI-Specialist Zertifizierungsprüfung auch international akzeptiert. Die Salesforce-AI-Specialist Zertifizierungsprüfungen haben auch breite IT-Zertifizierungen. Die Leute in der ganzen Welt wählen gerne die die Salesforce-AI-Specialist Zertifizierungsprüfung, um Erfolg im Berufsleben zu erlangen. In EchteFrage können Sie die Ihnen geeigneten Produkte zum Lernen wählen.

  33. I’m deeply thankful for your article, it really stuck with me. This C1000-161 latest mock exam set helped me climb the career ladder and get a salary raise. Now, it’s available for free to all. Wishing you all the best in your professional growth!

  36. Your article was truly unforgettable, thank you for sharing it. This C1000-138 valid torrent helped me get promoted and receive a salary increase. Now, it’s free for everyone. Wishing you success in your career journey!

  37. Die HPE7-A02 Prüfung ist ein neuer Wendepunkt in der IT-Branche. Sie werden der fachlich qualifizierte IT-Fachmann werden. Mit der Verbreitung und dem Fortschritt der Informationstechnik werden Sie Hunderte Online-Ressourcen sehen, die Fragen und Antworten zur HP HPE7-A02 Zertifizierungsprüfung bieten. Aber DeutschPrüfung ist der Vorläufer. Viele Leute wählen DeutschPrüfung, weil die Schulungsunterlagen zur HP HPE7-A02 Zertifizierungsprüfung von DeutschPrüfungI hnen Vorteile bringen und Ihren Traum verwirklichen können.

  41. Heutzutage herrscht in der IT-Branche ein heftiger Konkurrenz. Die Salesforce Salesforce-AI-Specialist Zertifizierungsprüfung wird Ihnen helfen, in der IT-Branche immer konkurrenzfähig zu bleiben. Im PrüfungGuide können Sie die Trainingsmaterialien für Salesforce-AI-Specialist Zertifizierungsprüfung bekommen. Unser Eliteteam wird Ihnen die richtigen und genauen Trainingsmaterialien für die Salesforce Salesforce-AI-Specialist Zertifizierungsprüfung bieten. Per die Lernmaterialien und die Examensübungen-und fragen von PrüfungGuide versprechen wir Ihnen, dass Sie die Prüfung beim ersten Versuch bestehen können, ohne dass Sie viel Zeit und Energie fürs Lernen verwenden.

  42. I definitely agree with your evaluation that Gessen seems overly concerned with making a grand claim regarding a problem of such a broad scope. Reading your comment made me think of another distinction between the dialogues of the essayists we’ve analyzed in class and of those Gessen calls upon in her piece. While Gessen clearly takes into consideration a broad time period, the dialogue between all scientists involved remains confined within close proximity, at least compared to the periods of years between the thoughtful insights of Havel, Crick, and Wedeen. Indeed, in her pursuit to answer such a current trend, Gessen lacks the hindsight to fully understand the issue. Despite a deep knowledge of what has led up to the unexplainable deaths, the matter seems too recent to be fully understood. Without distance from the problem, Gessen can only resort to such “silly generalizations” as she strives towards the deeper truth, that can perhaps be easier to discover with more time.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.