The Dangers of Walzer

Michael Walzer’s Moral Minimalism seems to make a series of assumptions are not only unacceptable from a social/political science point of view, but are dangerous when applied to any theories about current or past events. In particular, when he discusses his maximal meaning of morals we see him speak in generalities about the universal meanings about the signs that were being paraded through Prague or the general understanding about the immorality of totalitarian regimes, he seems to be speaking on behalf of all people everywhere across every time in a way that is blatantly overstepping his bounds as a political scientist. His evidence for the Prague demonstration is “What they meant by the ‘justice’ inscribed on their signs, however, was simple enough: an end to arbitrary arrests, equal and impartial law enforcement, the abolition of the privileges and prerogatives of the party elite -common, garden variety justice” (Walzer, 2). However, he gives himself room to maneuver when he says that their actual understandings of “justice” may be different. In this way, he is saying that there is a universal meaning based on a shared set of morals, but there is no way to pin down exactly what that meaning is. This is similar to Fukuyama’s “End of History” thesis where the author states that we are coming to the end of history and that there are no new ideas, but at the same time, he does not say when the end of history and some great convergence will actually occur.

On a more personal, and albeit biased, note, the idea of universal morals does not make sense to me as a whole. Even such fundamental moral rules in Western culture such as not taking the life of another human being (which Walzer addresses) are not a universal moral by which all humans abide as there are plenty of instances of ritual sacrifices or the killing of newborns that are part of the culture of other societies. With cases like these, the idea of a universal moral that we all understand is difficult to reconcile.

20 thoughts on “The Dangers of Walzer

  1. No hesitation, this is deserving of a like. Here’s the New C-THR94-2405 test dumps demo exam that boosted my career with a promotion and salary increase. It’s free today for all! Wishing you success in your career journey.

  2. Your article was truly inspiring, thank you for sharing it with me. This C-ARCON-2404 latest exam camp free set helped me climb the career ladder and get a salary raise. Now, it’s available for free to all. Wishing you all the best in your professional growth!

  3. Your article is breathtakingly good, thank you for sharing it! The New H13-624_V5.0 test questions helped me secure a promotion and raise. It’s now free to all. Wishing you success in your promotion journey!

  4. Um Ihnen zu helfen, ob die Qualität der Dumps gut sind und ob Sie sich für diese Dumps eignen, bieten PrüfungFrage Dumps Ihnen kostlose Demo in der Form von PDF-Versionen und Software-Versionen. Sie können diese kostlose Demo bei PrüfungFrage finden. Nach dem Probieren können Sie sich entscheiden, ob diese ISTQB CT-AI Prüfungsunterlagen zu kaufen. Und es kann auch diese Situation vermeiden, dass Sie bereuen, diese ISTQB CT-AI Prüfungsunterlagen ohne das Kennen der Qualität zu kaufen.

  5. Welche Schulungsunterlagen zur CompTIA CV0-003 Zertifizierungsprüfung sind die zuverlässigste unten zahlreichen Webseiten? Selbstvertsändlich sind die Lehrbücher von ZertPruefung die genauigste. ZertPruefung verfügt über professionelle ausgebildete Arbeitnehmer, Zertifizierungsexperten, Techniker sowie Sprachmaster, sie erforschen ständig die neuesten CompTIA CV0-003 Prüfung und aktualisieren sie. Deswegen können Sie ganz beruhigt unsere Schulungsunterlagen zur CompTIA CV0-003 Zertifizierungsprüfung benutzen, und wir versprechen Ihnen, dass Sie die CompTIA CV0-003 Zertifizierungsprüfung bestimmt bestehen können.

  6. I deeply appreciate your article, it was truly memorable. This UiPath-ABAv1 exam dumps pdf helped me achieve a promotion and pay raise. Now I’m sharing it for free with everyone. Wishing you all great success in your careers!

  7. I gained a ton of value from the article. This 700-245 latest test camp sheet helped me achieve a promotion and salary increase. Now it’s free for everyone. Wishing you all a smooth path to promotion!

  8. お客様の暇が少ないので、勉強する時間が少ないことを考えています。C-STC-2405試験資料は便利で、覚えやすいです。また、もう一つの特徴は時間を節約することです。つまり、C-STC-2405試験資料を短い時間で勉強すると、C-STC-2405試験を受けることができます。大切なのはC-STC-2405試験資料の的中率が高いです。

  9. I understand where you are coming from, but I think that the spreading of a universal, modern culture is exactly what Walzer was thinking about. There certainly used to be many cultures with vastly different morals than those we in the United States have today, but they are dying out. In their place, the morals that we today consider to be crucial came into play. This also ties into the “End of History” thesis. Western culture, as we know it, has spread across the globe, transforming the thought processes of billions of people. Certainly, there will be changes by region, but Walzer, in my mind, convincingly argues that these morals have generally become globally uniform.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.