Sensationalist journalism, not scientific analysis

Gessen’s claim that “Russia is dying of a broken heart” is misplaced in scientific or even social analysis. She attempts to use a kind of middle-range theory, such as the one Ziblatt advocates for, to describe a country of over 144 million people over a range of almost 100 years. Gessen completely fails to examine the scope conditions and any limitations on generalizing her (already questionable) findings. The conclusion that the death rate in Russia is due to cardiovascular disease is quite possibly a solid one – however, she fails to substantiate it with convincing evidence. It is true that the physiological outcome of stress, mediated by many deleterious effects of the hormone cortisol, can lead to immune suppression and increase the chance of contracting disease such as CVD. However, Gessen uses ungeneralizable and unsubstantiated evidence that in no way qualifies as scientific.

Gessen’s emotional approach, beginning with an (irrelevant) sob-story about how she lost many friends to AIDS in the US and then was told she shouldn’t be surprised that her Russian friends were dying as well – literally “crying on a friend’s shoulder” – is antithetical to any type of scientific study. While emotional appeals can be effective in journalism, Gessen’s article masquerades as scientific analysis of Russia’s high death rate, a quantitative statistic. Scientists of all kinds, including those in “soft” sciences, strive for impartiality because emotion leads to distortion such as confirmation bias. Gessen’s emotional connection to the country also dissuades her from considering what Scott proposed – that people may lie to analysts to portray themselves or their culture in a certain light. Parsons’ “long, unstructured interviews” offer only the perspectives of several in millions, and there is no guarantee that that these perspectives are reliable.

The weakest aspect of Gessen’s analysis is when she connects the “brief breaks in the downward spiral” with periods “of greater hope,” namely the Kruschev and Gorbachev eras. There is nothing that indicates causality between these eras and hope, or hope and low death rate. It would be more accurate to discuss the effects of less-repressive regimes and more open economies on, for example, food availability and nutrition, or stillbirths. Gessen states, “death and birth statistics appear to reflect nothing but despair.” Not only does she imply causality here, she implies exclusive causality! This is a huge oversight and inappropriate for any remotely scientific analysis.

23 thoughts on “Sensationalist journalism, not scientific analysis

  1. Es ist uns allen klar, dass das Hauptproblem in der IT-Branche ein Mangel an Qualität und Funktionalität ist. ZertPruefung stellt Ihnen alle notwendigen Schulungsunterlagen zur Huawei H12-821_V1.0-ENU Prüfung zur Verfügung. Ähnlich wie die reale Zertifizietungsprüfung verhelfen die Multiple-Choice-Fragen Ihnen zum Bestehen der Prüfung. Die Huawei H12-821_V1.0-ENU Prüfung Schulungsunterlagen von ZertPruefung sind überprüfte Prüfungsmaterialien. Alle diesen Fragen und Antworten zeigen unsere praktische Erfahrungen und Spezialisierung.

  2. Thank you for your fantastic article, it’s so thought-provoking! This is the H12-831_V1.0 prep guide exam that led to my promotion and salary increase, and it’s free today for all. Best of luck on your career path!

  3. This article gave me a new perspective, thank you for sharing! Here’s the 1z0-1109-24 certification exam dumps test that contributed to my promotion and salary increase. It’s free for everyone today—hope you all achieve your career goals soon!

  4. Thank you for your article, it was so insightful and inspiring. These NS0-516 reliable exam camp file questions were the key to my success. Grab them today for free to boost your career!

  5. Sie können jetzt SAP C-TS4FI-2023 Zertifikat erhalten. Unser ZertFragen bietet die neue Version von SAP C-TS4FI-2023 Prüfung. Sie brauchen nicht mehr, die neuesten Schulungsunterlagen von SAP C-TS4FI-2023 zu suchen. Weil Sie die besten Schulungsunterlagen von SAP C-TS4FI-2023 gefunden haben. Benutzen Sie beruhigt unsere C-TS4FI-2023 Schulungsunterlagen. Sie werden sicher die SAP C-TS4FI-2023 Zertifizierungsprüfung bestehen.

  6. This article has been very beneficial to me, and I have gained so much from it. The Preparation PMI-PBA Store exam papers are free! Best of luck to everyone preparing!

  7. Thank you for sharing this amazing article, it is truly breathtaking! The valuable content of CT-AI reliable braindumps sheet is free to all, designed to help you achieve success.

  8. 上帝是很公平的,每個人都是不完美的。就好比我,平時不努力,老大徒傷悲。現在的IT行業競爭壓力不言而喻大家都知道,每個人都想通過IT認證來提升自身的價值,我也是,可是這種對我們來說是太難太難了,所學的專業知識早就忘了,惡補那是不現實的,還好我在互聯網上看到了Fast2test CheckPoint的156-315.81.20考試培訓資料,有了它我就不用擔心我得考試了,Fast2test CheckPoint的156-315.81.20考試培訓資料真的很好,它的內容覆蓋面廣,而且針對性強,絕對比我自己復習去準備考試好,如果你也是IT行業中的一員,那就趕緊將Fast2test CheckPoint的156-315.81.20考試培訓資料加入購物車吧,不要猶豫,不要徘徊,Fast2test CheckPoint的156-315.81.20考試培訓資料絕對是成功最好的伴侶。

  9. 我們的PDFExamDumps是一個為多種IT認證考試的人提供準確的考試材料的專業網站。我們的PDFExamDumps是一個可以為很多IT人士提升自己的職業目標。我們的IT精英團隊的力量會讓你難以置信。你可以先嘗試我們PDFExamDumps為你們提供的免費下載關於CIW 1D0-623認證考試的部分考題及答案來測我們的可靠性。

  10. 所有的Huawei職員都知道,H13-629_V3.0認證考試的資格是不容易拿到的。但是,參加H13-629_V3.0認證考試獲得資格又是提升自己能力以及更好地證明自己的價值的途徑,所以不得不選擇。那麼,難道沒有一個簡單的方法可以讓大家更容易地通過Huawei認證考試嗎?當然有了。PDFExamDumps的考古題就是一個最好的方法。PDFExamDumps有你需要的所有資料,絕對可以滿足你的要求。你可以到PDFExamDumps的网站了解更多的信息,找到你想要的考试资料。

  11. I really appreciate your article, it has been an eye-opening experience. DASM valid test lab questions questions shared for free. Best of luck in your exam preparations!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.