Meritocracy

In this piece, Gatto claims that the educational system was created as a tool for social control of the masses. Accordingly, meritocracy is an extension of this means of control, separating the masses by their utility to the social machine. The point of grades and ranking in such a system are to facilitate this process of differentiation, elevating the few the system deems deserving to positions of power while consigning the rest to roles of subservient cogs in the machine.

Considered in this light, institutions such as Williams are no more than an extension of this very system, perpetuating the existing power structure and magnifying the distinctions between the winners in this system and everyone else. Indeed a liberal arts education is a reflection of this elitist view of society. As quoted in the Gatto piece, Woodrow Wilson himself said a liberal arts education was to be confined to a selected few while the rest “forgo the privileges of a liberal education and fit themselves to perform specific difficult manual tasks” (37).

Williams goes so far as to active flaunt its role in this system, specifically culling  “students of high academic ability and great personal promise” in order to provide a “privilege that creates the opportunity and responsibility to serve society at large” (Williams Mission Statement). That this purposeful segmentation of society to perpetual elite rule seems virtuous both on the part of the institutions as well as those subject to its practices reflects the extent to which this notion of meritocracy has permeated our modern condition.

 

28 thoughts on “Meritocracy

  1. Sie haben schon die Prüfungsmaterialien zur SAP C_STC_2405 Zertifizierung von Zertpruefung gesehen. Es ist doch Zeit, eine Wahl zu treffen. Sie können auch andere Produkte wählen, aber unser Zertpruefung wird Ihnen die größten Interessen bringen. Mit Zertpruefung werden Sie eine glänzende Zukunft haben, eine bessere Berufsaussichten in der IT-Branche haben und effizient arbeiten.

  2. IT업종 종사자분들은 모두 승진이나 연봉인상을 위해 자격증을 취득하려고 최선을 다하고 계실것입니다. 하지만 쉴틈없는 야근에 시달려서 공부할 시간이 없어 스트레스가 많이 쌓였을것입니다. KoreaDumps의Huawei인증 H19-338_V3.0덤프로Huawei인증 H19-338_V3.0시험공부를 해보세요. 시험문제커버율이 높아 덤프에 있는 문제만 조금의 시간의 들여 공부하신다면 누구나 쉽게 시험패스가능합니다.

  3. This article has given me a new understanding of this field, and it’s truly inspiring. Here’s the C_S4CPR_2402 valid test prep test that helped me get promoted and raise my salary. It’s free today—hope it helps you with your career goals!

  4. I’m very thankful for your article, it left a lasting impression. I’m offering the D-DS-FN-23 latest exam guide exam that helped me land my promotion and pay raise. It’s free today—good luck achieving your career goals!

  5. I really appreciate this inspiring article, thank you for sharing! Free Valid test OGEA-103 questions explanations resources—unlock promotions and salary increases today!

  6. This article really expanded my views, thank you for the fantastic share! Get free Reliable 300-510 exam camp questions to elevate your IT abilities. Best of luck in your exams!

  7. I can’t express how much I appreciate your article, it was truly memorable. Here are the 300-300 latest test objectives questions for free. Best of luck to all exam-takers!

  8. After reading this article, I have a more thorough understanding of the related topics. I reached my career goals thanks to the Reliable test CQE lab questions exam, and now you can access it for free!

  9. CertShikenは、受験者向けの300-300J試験資料を作成するための専門的なプラットフォームです。300-300J試験に合格し、関連する認定をより効率的で簡単な方法で取得できるようお手伝いします。当社の300-300J試験材料の優れた品質とリーズナブルな価格により、当社の300-300J試験トレントは、国際分野の他のメーカーよりも価格が優れているだけでなく、多くの点で明らかに優れています。 300-300J試験問題集の合格率は99%〜100%であり、これは市場で独特です。

  10. Your article is breathtaking, thank you for sharing! Sharing the Exam HPE7-A04 Tests exam that helped me with my career advancement and raise—it’s free for all today. Best of luck on your professional journey!

  11. Thank you for your article, it really provided me with a new outlook. Get your hands on the New A00-485 test testking test that helped me achieve a promotion and salary increase, and it’s available for free today. I hope you hit your career goals soon!

  12. Professionals are able to show their MuleSoft expertise by passing the MCD-Level-1 dumps, which gauges their understanding of the MuleSoft Any Point Platform’s foundations. Some people may run into websites or people that are selling MCD-Level-1 exam dumps while studying for the test. Exam dumps are discussed in this article along with why they are unwise and study advice for the MCD-Level-1 exam.

  13. I do not agree with your claim that Williams works as an extension of a hierarchical system that schooling initially creates. In fact, I think that Williams makes a pointed effort in attempting to counteract many negative results of a meritocracy. Consider the efforts that Williams makes at financial aid (we have one of best in the country), and careful selection of a diverse student body from a variety of backgrounds. With this in mind, I think it is actually positive that Williams culls “students of high academic ability and great personal promise,” because those students are also ones who come from a variety of class, racial, and ethnic backgrounds. Yes, there is always more that Williams or another high level institution could do to level the playing field within society; however, I do think that Williams stands out from other institutions that are much more complicit in their role within a meritocracy.

  14. I’d agree with the claim that Williams College and peer institutions perpetuate the hierarchical system Gatto writes about. I think this is a system that positively contributes to society overall, however. So, I don’t really have an issue with it and think that, with society’s (and especially the job market’s) current infrastructure, moving away from this system would create more problems than it would solve.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.