Material Modernity

Professor Daniel Lerner, in The Grocer and the Chief, assumes what many Americans also assume, which is that modernity is the pursuit of a material improvement from traditional or subsistence lifestyles. Lerner’s assumptions are obvious in his characterization of the Chief as a self-sufficient and martial man, and his preoccupation with the Grocer as a caricature of “modern” culture and forward-thinking. The Chief values individual valor and his own position of power within his village, which Lerner conflates with holding on to tradition. The Grocer’s awareness of cinema and coffeehouses, on the other hand, seems to Lerner to signify a desire for a life marked by modern technology.  One of Lerner’s key assumptions is that these men are unwilling to change and that while collective society may force alterations in daily life and the economy, individuals remain the same, conveniently representing distinct ideals of personhood.

Lerner concludes his piece stating that the Grocer has won out in an imaginary contest between tradition and material modernization.  However, he neglects the important fact that the Chief has notably modernized himself.  As Balgat is incorporated into Ankara, the Chief incorporates himself and his family into the changed society.  Yes, the Muhtar keeps a small grove of trees, but he allows his sons, whom he once saw as heirs he must make ready for war, to open moderately successful westernized businesses.  The Chief, over four years, gives up his farmland and his most integral values of makes a successful man.  In this way, I believe that Lerner makes the same mistake as Tosun did in judging based on appearances.  Lerner does not consider the effects of modernization on the individuals who adapt to their current situation and the interplay between individuals and material change within a modernizing society.

8 thoughts on “Material Modernity

  1. Thank you for this article, it’s left a lasting impression on me. Here’s the S1000-008 training topics exam that boosted my career with a promotion and salary increase. It’s free today for all! Wishing you success in your career journey.

  2. ExamPassdump는EMC D-ECS-DY-23인증시험을 아주 쉽게 패스할 수 있도록 도와드리는 사이트입니다. ExamPassdump의 엘리트한 전문가가 끈임 없는 노력으로 최고의EMC D-ECS-DY-23자료를 만들었습니다. 이 자료로 여러분은 100%EMC의D-ECS-DY-23인증시험을 패스할 수 있으며, ExamPassdump을 선택함으로 성공을 선택한 것입니다. ExamPassdump가 제공하는 시험가이드로 효과적인 학습으로 많은 분들이 모두 인증시험을 패스하였습니다. 이건 모두 ExamPassdump 인증시험덤프로 공부하였기 때문입니다. 그 중EMC D-ECS-DY-23인증시험을 패스한 분들도 모두 ExamPassdump인증시험덤프를 사용하였기 때문입니다.

  3. Through reading this article, I feel that I have made great progress. Want to get promoted and earn a higher salary? These SK0-005 valid test questions fee questions helped me do it, and I’m giving them to you for free today!

  4. 花に欺く言語紹介より自分で体験したほうがいいです。IBM S1000-007問題集は我々Xhs1991では直接に無料のダウンロードを楽しみにしています。弊社の経験豊かなチームはあなたに最も信頼性の高いIBM S1000-007問題集備考資料を作成して提供します。IBM S1000-007問題集の購買に何か質問があれば、我々の職員は皆様のお問い合わせを待っています。

  5. これは高効率の時代であり、IBMおそらくC1000-107証明書を通じてのみ競争力を証明する方法が最も簡単です。 ただし、他の問題に巻き込まれる可能性があるため、多くの人にとって時間は限られています。CertShiken C1000-107学習教材を使用すると、すべての問題が疑いなく簡単に解決されます。 信頼できる有効なC1000-107試験トレントだけでなく、最も柔軟な学習方法も提供できます。 また、他の多くのお客様と同様に、IBM Netcool Operations Insight v1.6.1 Administration試験に合格する必要があることを確認できます。

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.