Matching Expectations of Democracy in a Third Grade Classroom

Posted on by

Analyzing the portrayal of democracy in “Please Vote For Me” can be done with respect to either democracy in theory or in practice. As far as the former, on the surface, the third graders’ classroom’s version of democracy follows Dahl’s criteria: the election of officials, the right to vote, the right to run for office, the right to express themselves for all. However, the students are unable to fully achieve democracy due to a lack of appreciation for all the details of the democratic process, or democracy in practice. Specifically, as Schimitter and Karl argue, fairly conducted elections are crucial to democracy, and while there was indeed competition between the three students, bribery plays a role in giving the votes to Luo Lei. Neither were elected officials being held accountable for their actions: the students do not utilize their right to confront Luo Lei’s authoritarian manner. Also, Schmitter and Karl emphasize deliberation between the people as important to the democratic process, and the film doesn’t emphasize the students taking part in this (aside from interactions directly with the nominees who tried to sway them). The lack of these conversations could potentially be due to an apathy on the part of the students, a lack of caring that effectively destroys democracy as it removes the role of the citizens. Perhaps too however, the expectation of these students to practice democracy in their classroom is too great. In their setting, the students face two extremes with respect to social order: discipline outside the classroom and disorder within it. As far as the liberal democracy argument, the students must achieve order in the classroom (not the chaos of bullying one minute and everyone crying the next) before they can establish democracy. And ultimately, without knowing the terms associated with government (ie. vote, dictator, manager), they lack the insight about politics in general.

44 thoughts on “Matching Expectations of Democracy in a Third Grade Classroom”

  3. I’ve learned many valuable experiences from this article. Sharing the New AZ-140 test format test that contributed to my promotion and salary hike, and it’s free for you to access today. Best of luck in achieving your career aspirations!

  6. ExamPassdump에서 Network Appliance인증 NS0-528덤프를 구입하시면 퍼펙트한 구매후 서비스를 제공해드립니다. Network Appliance인증 NS0-528덤프가 업데이트되면 업데이트된 최신버전을 무료로 서비스로 드립니다. 시험에서 불합격성적표를 받으시면 덤프구매시 지불한 덤프비용은 환불해드립니다.

  7. IT業界で仕事している皆さんはIT認定試験の資格の重要性をよく知っていているでしょう。IT認定試験には多くの種類があります。現在最も人気がある試験もいろいろあります。例えばCRT-450-JPN認定試験などです。その中の試験、どちらを受験しましたか。もし一つの認証資格を持っていないなら、IT認定試験を申し込んで試験の資格を取得する必要があります。試験を受ける予定があれば、急いでMogiExamへ来て必要な情報を見つけましょう。MogiExamはあなたがCRT-450-JPN認定試験に合格する保障ですから。

  8. Thank you so much for your article, it made a lasting impact on me. Level up your IT abilities—free Reliable CDCS test camp for you! Wishing you all the best!

  9. PDFExamDumps 考題大師的擬真試題覆蓋了真實的考試真題，已經成為考生通過 F5 402 考试的首選學習資料。402 考試主要用於具有較高水準的實施顧問能力，獲取證書，以確保考生有一個堅實的專業基礎知識，有利於他們將此能力企業專業化。準備 F5 的 402 考試的考生，需要熟練了解我們的擬真試題，快速完成測試，就能順利通過考試。

  12. This article has caused me to re-examine many things, and I have greatly benefited from it. Thanks to the Exam FCP_FAZ_AD-7.4 certification cost system, I got a promotion and a salary increase. Now, I’m making it free for everyone. Wishing you all a swift rise in your careers!

  14. Thank you so much for your article, it’s something I’ll remember. This is the MB-330 reliable exam pattern exam I passed for my promotion and salary raise. It’s free for you today—hope you reach your career milestones!

  19. Chancen gehören zu den Leuten, wer gut vorbereitet hat. Wenn unsere Chance vor uns vorhanden ist, können wir sie erfolgreich greifen? Die OCEG GRCA exam Fragen können die Garantie für Sie sein, GRCA Prüfung abzulegen. Mit diesen Dumps können Sie viel Zeit sparen und hohe Effektivität haben. Sie können ihre Besonderheit und hohe Qualität kennen, wenn sie die echten Fragen und Antworten von Pass4Test benutzen. Es ist wirklich ein kürzester Weg zu Ihrem Erfolg. Damit können Sie sich auf OCEG GRCA exam voll vorbereiten.

  21. MogiExamのサイトでは、あなたがH3CのGB0-343認定試験を気楽に準備することができますし、普通なミスを避けるのもできます。MogiExamのH3CのGB0-343試験トレーニング資料は高度に認証されたIT領域の専門家の経験と創造を含めているものです。それは正確性が高くて、権威性も高いです。MogiExamは君にとって、ベストなチョイスだといっても良いです。

  22. Truly an impressive article, I’m grateful for your share. Here’s the Valid C-C4H46-2408 test cost test that helped me get a promotion and pay raise. It’s free for everyone today. Best of luck with your career!

  23. This article has been very helpful to me, giving me new perspectives on many issues. Latest test SAFe-SASM dumps demo has fantastic materials, and it’s offered to you free of charge.

  25. I’m deeply moved by your article, thank you for sharing this insight! Thanks to the Reliable study guide DVA-C02 ebook system, I got a promotion and a salary increase. Now, I’m making it free for everyone. Wishing you all a swift rise in your careers!

  26. 如果你想選擇通過 Cisco 300-815 認證考試來使自己在如今競爭激烈的IT行業中地位更穩固，讓自己的IT職業能力變得更強大，你必須得具有很強的專業知識。而且通過 Cisco 300-815 認證考試也不是很簡單的。或許通過Cisco 300-815認證考試是你向IT行業推廣自己的一個敲門磚，但是不一定需要花費大量的時間和精力來復習相關知識，你可以選擇用我們的 NewDumps的產品，是專門針對IT認證考試相關的培訓工具。

  28. The viewpoints in the article have sparked many new ideas in me, and I’ve greatly benefited. The CCSP exam quick prep exam is almost here. Please send me good vibes!

  29. I learned so much from the article—it was truly beneficial. The content in Latest study DP-600 questions sheet is rich and free of charge, created with your success in mind.

  30. Wenn Sie die Fragen und Antworten zur PECB ISO-IEC-27001-Lead-Auditor-Deutsch Prüfung von ZertSoft kaufen, können Sie ihre wichtige Vorbereitung im leben treffen und die Fragenkataloge von guter Qualität bekommen. Kaufen Sie unsere Produkte heute, dann öffnen Sie sich eine Tür, um eine bessere Zukunft zu haben. Sie können auch mit weniger Mühe den großen Erfolg erzielen.

  31. The content of the article is rich and profound, and I’ve learned a lot from it. My promotion and raise were made possible by the Latest TMMi-P_Syll2020 exam passing score questions—today, I’m sharing them with you at no cost!

  34. IT인증시험에 도전해보려는 분들은 회사에 다니는 분들이 대부분입니다. 승진을 위해서나 연봉협상을 위해서나 자격증 취득은 지금시대의 필수입니다. ITDumpsKR의GIAC인증 GSLC덤프는 회사다니느라 바쁜 나날을 보내고 있는 분들을 위해 준비한 시험준비공부자료입니다. ITDumpsKR의GIAC인증 GSLC덤프를 구매하여 pdf버전을 공부하고 소프트웨어버전으로 시험환경을 익혀 시험보는게 두렵지 않게 해드립니다. 문제가 적고 가격이 저렴해 누구나 부담없이 애용 가능합니다. ITDumpsKR의GIAC인증 GSLC덤프를 데려가 주시면 기적을 안겨드릴게요.

  36. 我々はMB-500試験を準備しているあなたに便利をもたらすために、PDF版、ソフト版、オンライン版の3つの異なるバーションを提供しています。PDF版のMB-500問題集を利用したら、紙でプリントすることができて読みやすいです。ソフト版であなたは試験の環境でMB-500模擬試験をすることができて複数のパソコンで使用することができます。また、オンライン版を通して、どの電子製品でも使うことができて、オンライン版の機能はソフト版のと大体同じです。

  37. This article is incredibly motivating, thank you for sharing it! Free Detailed RWVCPC study plan shared to elevate your IT skills. Wishing you success in your exams!

  40. Suchen Sie nach die geeignetsten Prüfungsunterlagen der AVIXA CTS-I? Sorgen Sie noch um das Ordnen der Unterlagen? ZertPruefung als ein professioneller Lieferant der Software der IT-Zertifizierungsprüfung haben Ihnen die umfassendsten Unterlagen der AVIXA CTS-I vorbereitet. Jetzt können Sie Zeit fürs Suchen gespart und direkt auf die AVIXA CTS-I Prüfung vorbereiten!

  41. This article is incredible, thank you for sharing it! The Latest FOCP study materials exam questions are free for everyone—unlock career growth and salary increases!

  44. I think you touch on a very valuable point towards the end of your post. It seems that we, the viewers, come into this documentary expecting these children will operate in a fully democratic manner. This seems very foolish. Not only are they children, they live in a country where democracy is not fully practiced. Therefore, they depend on their parents’ definition which is problematic as their parents have never lived in a democracy either. Altogether, it seems unfair to blame elementary school children in China for failing to conduct a fair election.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.