Lerner’s One Path to Modernity

In “The Grocer and the Chief,” Lerner assumes that development and modernity in Balgat are dependent on the abandonment of certain traditional Turkish values. Referencing how the village used to be, Lerner mentions, “To reveal a desire for money is —Allah defend us!—an impiety.” It seems that, according to Lerner, when villagers start to care about money—when they buy bus tickets, clothing, food, etc.— is when progress occurs. Additionally, Lerner remarks, “Obviously, this was to be on the house, following the paradoxical Turksih custom of giving gratis to those who can best afford to pay.”  Here, Lerner appears to be making fun of Turkish tradition, assuming that with modernity comes the acceptance of inherently Western values. Lerner fails to consider that even though their society has changed, villagers in Balgat may still place higher importance on tradition and showing respect than the Western value of doing anything you can to make a buck.

Similarly, Lerner shares that demand for “modern” clothing increased as “more and more men went into the labor market of Ankara, first discarding their shalvars (the billowing bloomers of traditional garb in which Western cartoon always still portray the (sultan in a harem scene).” Again, Lerner tastelessly associates modernity and development with the abandonment of tradition, assuming that the villagers would rather wear U.S. Army surplus-style clothes rather than their traditional shalvars now that they are “modern.”  While Lerner does present a clear and interesting depiction of how the village has changed in just a few years, I think his tendency to make fun of everything that doesn’t align with Western culture undermines any meaningful claims he may have made about the reasons behind “advancement” in Balgat.

46 thoughts on “Lerner’s One Path to Modernity

  1. Die SASInstitute A00-415 Zertifizierungsprüfung ist eine wichtige SASInstitute Zertifizierungsprüfung. Aber es ist nicht einfach, die SASInstitute A00-415 Zertifizierungsprüfung zu bestehen. Um den Druck der Kandidaten zu entlasten und Zeit und Energie zu ersparen hat PrüfungFrage viele Prüfungsmaterialien entwickelt. So können Sie im PrüfungFrage die geeignete und effziente Trainingsmethode wählen, um die A00-415 Prüfung zu bestehen.

  2. Absolutely brilliant content, no hesitation to like it. Here’s the HPE2-B02 valid study questions pdf test that helped me get a promotion and pay raise. It’s free for everyone today. Best of luck with your career!

  3. 你想在IT行業中大顯身手嗎,你想得到更專業的認可嗎?快來報名參加RCNI資格認證考試進一步提高自己的技能吧。Fast2test可以幫助你實現這一願望。這裏有專業的知識,強大的考古題,優質的服務,可以讓你高速高效的掌握知識技能,在考試中輕鬆過關,讓自己更加接近成功之路。

  4. Your article was a breath of fresh air, thank you for sharing it. With the Test CISSP dates, I secured a promotion and salary increase. Now it’s free for everyone. Best of luck on your career advancement!

  5. Thank you for this amazing article, it left a profound impression on me. Pass4sure 2V0-71.23 dumps pdf helped me secure a promotion and salary boost, and today, I’m making it available for free!

  6. What a captivating article, I truly appreciate your sharing it. Thanks to the C-SEC-2405 reliable test cram, I received a promotion and raise. It’s now free to all. Hope your promotions come soon!

  7. The depth and breadth of the article left a strong impression on me. The 2V0-31.24 free updates helped me move forward in my career with a promotion and salary increase. Now, I’m sharing it for free. Wishing you career success!

  8. The depth and scope of the article opened my eyes. Sharing the C-C4H320-34 test name exam that helped me with my career advancement and raise—it’s free for all today. Best of luck on your professional journey!

  9. I’m very thankful for your article, it left a lasting impression. 700-805 reliable exam answers was key to my career and salary growth. Now, I’m sharing it for free with you!

  10. Thank you for sharing this inspiring article with us! This Valid CRT-261 test practice set helped me climb the career ladder and get a salary raise. Now, it’s available for free to all. Wishing you all the best in your professional growth!

  11. I’m sincerely grateful for your article, it left a strong impression. This is the New 1z0-1042-24 test vce exam that helped me advance in my career with a promotion and raise. It’s free today for all of you. Wishing you success!

  12. Thank you for your brilliant article, it truly left me in awe! Free access to CTFL4 visual cert exam’s extensive content is offered, with the aim of supporting you.

  13. 当社は、D-PM-MN-23の実際の質問が最も信頼できるものであることを保証できます。約10年の開発を経て、高品質のD-PM-MN-23学習教材を開発し、すべてのお客様に忍耐するために努力を払っています。さらに、D-PM-MN-23学習資料が古くなっているのではないかと思われるかもしれません。 D-PM-MN-23の実際の質問は高速で更新されます。また、D-PM-MN-23テストガイドを1年間無料でお楽しみいただけますので、時間とお金を節約できます。最新のD-PM-MN-23学習資料をメールでお送りします。

  14. SAP 인증C-S4CS-2408시험에 도전해보려고 하는데 공부할 내용이 너무 많아 스트레스를 받는 분들은 지금 보고계시는 공부자료는 책장에 다시 넣으시고KoreaDumps의SAP 인증C-S4CS-2408덤프자료에 주목하세요. KoreaDumps의 SAP 인증C-S4CS-2408덤프는 오로지 SAP 인증C-S4CS-2408시험에 대비하여 제작된 시험공부가이드로서 시험패스율이 100%입니다. 시험에서 떨어지면 덤프비용전액환불해드립니다.

  15. Your article was truly unforgettable, thank you for sharing it. I was promoted and received a raise with the help of the PCNSE study demo. Now it’s available for free to all. Best wishes for your promotions!

  16. Fortinet인증 FCP_ZCS_AD-7.4시험을 어떻게 패스할가 고민그만하고Itcertkr의Fortinet 인증FCP_ZCS_AD-7.4시험대비 덤프를 데려가 주세요.가격이 착한데 비해 너무나 훌륭한 덤프품질과 높은 적중율, Itcertkr가 아닌 다른곳에서 찾아볼수 없는 혜택입니다.

  17. SAPのC-THR82-2405試験に受かることを通じて現在の激しい競争があるIT業種で昇進したくて、IT領域で専門的な技能を強化したいのなら、豊富なプロ知識と長年の努力が必要です。SAPのC-THR82-2405試験に受かるのはあなたが自分をIT業種にアピールする方法の一つです。でも、試験に合格するために大量な時間とエネルギーを費やすことはなく、Tech4ExamのSAPのC-THR82-2405試験トレーニング資料を選んだらいいです。Tech4Examのトレーニング資料はIT認証試験に受かるために特別に研究されたものですから、この資料を手に入れたら難しいSAPのC-THR82-2405認定試験に気楽に合格することができるようになります。

  18. ExamPassdump의 인지도는 고객님께서 상상하는것보다 훨씬 높습니다.많은 분들이ExamPassdump의 덤프공부가이드로 IT자격증 취득의 꿈을 이루었습니다. ExamPassdump에서 출시한 Microsoft인증 SC-400덤프는 IT인사들이 자격증 취득의 험난한 길에서 없어서는 안될중요한 존재입니다. ExamPassdump의 Microsoft인증 SC-400덤프를 한번 믿고 가보세요.시험불합격시 덤프비용은 환불해드리니 밑져봐야 본전 아니겠습니까?

  19. Your article truly left me in awe, thank you for sharing! This is the Braindumps D-PDD-OE-23 downloads exam I took to get my promotion and pay raise, now available to you for free today. I hope you reach your professional goals soon!

  20. Lerner likes Turkish traditions. I think he sees them as cozy and cute. I do not think that Lerner is making fun of Turkish traditions, but rather he is praising the Balgat villagers for moving towards a secular view of life that encompasses capitalistic and western ideals. He does not have a negative outlook on old customs, but the road to success is paved with modernity. Lerner, like many other Western journalists, have grown up on the teachings that countries who emulate other modern countries are moving to the right side of History. Yes, the article is skewed in that sense but it does not come from a place of malice; instead, it is written on the ignorance that many other Americans share with Lerner. He does think that the loss of some of those steadfast truths are essential for the creation of a better world.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.