Lerner’s Idea of Modernity

Posted on by

Lerner is very upfront with his sympathies for the Grocer in his article. He mentions his feeling of sadness when he learned that the Grocer had died. We are made to believe that the Grocer is the prime example of modernity. For example, the author writes, “As one saw it now, the Grocer had shown the way…” While it is certainly true that the Grocer had values consistent with the future development of Turkey, it seems that Lerner primarily believed this because he saw the Grocer as a Western figure. Among other things, he continuously points out the Grocer’s idealization of the United States. Through the story of the Grocer, it feels that Lerner is arguing that the only way to modernize is to imitate the West. Perhaps the best example of this is when the Chief’s son opens his store. Lerner writes, “The Grocer’s words of aspiration came leaping back to mind…His dream house had been built in Balgat – in less time than even he might have forecast – and by none other than the Chief!” This struck me as a strange sentence. It seems that the Chief’s son had no real agency, he was simply following the example of the Grocer. This is not the only example. Every development in Balgat is traced back to the Grocer. In this way, Lerner westernized the development of Balgat by explaining it through the vision of the Grocer.

48 thoughts on “Lerner’s Idea of Modernity”

  5. Thank you for the article; it really stood out and caught my attention. Latest test AD0-E716 duration provides a range of useful materials for free, hoping they help you progress.

  6. Wenn wir am Anfang die Fragenkataloge zur ISQI CTAL-ATT Zertifizierungsprüfung bieteten, haben wir niemals geträumt, dass wir so einen guten Ruf bekommen können. Wir geben Ihnen die unglaubliche Garantie. Wenn Sie die Produkte von PrüfungGuide für Ihre ISQI CTAL-ATT Zertifizierungsprüfung benutzen, versprechen wir Ihnen, die Prüfung 100% zu bestehen.

  8. Huawei　H19-431_V1.0認定試験の難しさで近年にほとんどの受験生は資格認定試験に合格しなっかたと良く知られます。だから、我々社の有効な試験問題集は長年にわたりHuawei　H19-431_V1.0認定資格試験問題集作成に取り組んだIT専門家によって書いてます。実際の試験に表示される質問と正確な解答はあなたのHuawei　H19-431_V1.0認定資格試験合格を手伝ってあげます。

  12. Sie können kostenlos die Demo auf der Website PrüfungFrage.de herunterladen, um unsere Zuverlässigkeit zu bestätigen. Ich glaube, Sie werden sicher nicht enttäuscht sein. Die neuesten Fragen und Antworten zur SMRP CMRP Zertifizierungsprüfung von PrüfungFrage sind den realen Prüfungsthemen sehr ähnlich. Vielleicht haben Sie auch die einschlägige SMRP CMRP Zertifizierungsprüfung Schulungsunterlagen in anderen Büchern oder auf anderen Websites gesehen, würden Sie nach dem Vergleich finden, dass Sie doch aus PrüfungFrage stammen. Die Testantworten zur SMRP CMRP Zertifizierungsprüfung von PrüfungFrage sind umfassender, die orginalen Prüfungsthemen, die von den Erfahrungsreichen Expertenteams nach ihren Erfahrungen und Kenntnissen bearbeitet, enthalten.

  24. This article is truly a breath of fresh air, thank you for sharing it! The New GB0-372-ENU study materials questions were the stepping stones to my career success, and today I’m giving them away for free!

  25. PassTIP의 ISQI CAE덤프는 IT업계에 오랜 시간동안 종사한 전문가들의 끊임없는 노력과 지금까지의 노하우로 만들어낸ISQI CAE시험대비 알맞춤 자료입니다. PassTIP의 ISQI CAE덤프만 공부하시면 여러분은 충분히 안전하게 ISQI CAE시험을 패스하실 수 있습니다. PassTIP ISQI CAE덤프의 도움으로 여러분은 IT업계에서 또 한층 업그레이드 될것입니다

  26. Wenn Sie sich um die SAP P-BTPA-2408 Zertifizierungsprüfung bemühen, kann PrüfungGuide Ihnen helfen, Ihren Traum zu verwirklichen. Die Übungen zur SAP P-BTPA-2408 Zertifizierungsprüfung werden von der Praxis prüft. Die Schulungsunterlagen zur SAP P-BTPA-2408 Zertifizierungsprüfung sind von guter Qualität, die Ihnen helfen, die SAP P-BTPA-2408 Zertifizierungsprüfung zu bestehen und ein IT-Expert zu werden.

  28. I’m amazed by this article, thank you for sharing it. Free access to Reliable CCSP exam pattern materials—your key to climbing the career ladder and boosting your salary!

  31. I’m truly moved by your article, it left a lasting impression. I’m sharing the 1Z0-902 Practice exam pdf questions that made my promotion and raise possible—get them for free!

  34. Thank you for the article; it really stood out and caught my attention. TCC-C01 exam certification cost is a free resource, offering rich content to aid your learning experience.

  38. Through reading this article, I feel that I have made great progress. Here’s the OMG-OCSMP-MU100 reliable test preparation exam that was part of my promotion and pay raise—now shared with you for free today. Wishing you all success in your career paths!

  44. DES-3612試験の厳密な分析と要約により、学習内容を把握しやすくし、受験者の理解を超えた部分を簡素化しました。さらに、インターフェイスをより直感的にするために、図と例を追加して説明を表示します。 DES-3612試験の質問は学習のプレッシャーを軽減し、Q＆Aを少なくしてより重要な情報を伝え、DES-3612トレーニング資料で学習すれば最高の使用経験を提供します。また、99％から100％の高い合格率により、DES-3612試験は非常に簡単です。

  46. I also agree with your assessment that Lerner identifies with the Grocer because of a sense of familiarity and Western values. In some ways, the Grocer is similar to Tom Doniphon in The Man Who Shot Liberty Valance; both individuals helped usher in modernity into their respective environment, and both were forgotten over time as modernity fully took root. What does the forgetting of intermediate individuals (between the traditionalist past and the modern future) say about culture and society?

  47. I also completely agree with your take on Lerner’s association of the West with the Grocer. I think it is a great connection with and further evidence to a lot of the ideas laid out by Gray in his Al-Qaeda book. Not only is so much of the “anti-modern” rhetoric/ideas/progressions by states in fact, modern, but the bulk of this “anti-modern” modernization, if that makes sense, is rooted in Western philosophy, as Gray lays out.

  48. I completely agree that Lerner likes the Grocer because he senses that the Grocer wants to be more like Lerner than like the other villagers. The Grocer represents the path towards Western thought and culture, but he has died and been forgotten about now that Balgat is “modern.” I wonder if it has any significance that the Chief and his sons live and get to enjoy the new bus and the clothing stores but the Grocer is not remembered or thought of by anyone other than Western researchers like Lerner.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.