The claim Masha Gessen makes in The Dying Russians – that Russia is experiencing a depopulation crisis due to the people’s loss of hope – is questionable at best, and nearly impossible to believe at worst. While I’m not fundamentally opposed to the notion that something like a loss of hope can lead to a less healthy population with a consequently higher mortality rate, Gessen doesn’t really manage to convince me that this is what has been happening in Russia.
Gessen starts off on the right foot by citing anthropological works like Michelle Parson’s Dying Unneeded and describing her research. Regrettably, she soon seemingly tries to support her claim by ruling out other potential causes (drinking, smoking, etc. ) of the mortality crisis based on statistical data. I see this as an improper method that has harmed the credibility of her paper. Statistical data alone is arguably insufficient evidence to rule out a cause of Russia’s high mortality Also, any kind of “ruling out” methodology for research requires a much more expansive scope than what Gessen allows. Even if we ignore the faults in her methodology, such a claim will always seem doubtful to many.
If we accept Gessen’s conclusion as correct, then the mortality crisis starts to sound a lot like the protests talked about in texts like Lisa Wedeen’s Acting ‘As If’: Symbolic Politics and Social Control in Syria and James C. Scott’s Normal Exploitation, Normal Resistance. In this case, the Russian population protests a government that gives them nothing with shocking fertility and mortality rates. A notable difference between these protests and those described in the aforementioned texts, however, is that these protests seem to be subconscious – it’s not like Russians are knowingly choosing to get heart attacks. This was a major point of interest in the paper for me, as it got me thinking about how (or if) subconscious protest even exists.
Depopulation won’t please the government, but how can an action be considered rebellious if it is not even executed consciously? My opinion is that it can’t be – protest requires a mindful decision to defy your oppressor in some way or form. In fact, I think that this decision is the greatest qualifier for protest. Therefore, I can’t interpret the depopulation crisis as some kind of rebellious action or display against the Russian government.
Great stuff, I’m liking this without question. About to sit the NS0-516 valid exam collection file exam. Wishing for good luck!
It really broadened my horizons. I’m offering the PSE-SWFW-Pro-24 exam topics pdf exam that helped me land my promotion and pay raise. It’s free today—good luck achieving your career goals!
I found the article to be highly educational. Access the comprehensive content of Latest D-PDC-DY-23 exam online for free, designed to help you achieve your goals.
What a stunning article, thank you for sharing this amazing piece! A00-420 exam registration questions shared for free! Best of luck in your exam preparations!
Thank you so much for your article, it really struck me. The ISOIEC20000LI latest exam cram sheet file questions are essential for your career—get them for free now!
It provided me with so much to reflect on. Good luck to me on my H19-301_V3.0 new test collection sheet exam! Hoping for great results!
What an extraordinary piece of writing, thank you for sharing! Sharing the free New S1000-008 practice questions sheet test questions—your key to career advancement and higher earnings!
PassTIP에서는 소프트웨어버전과 PDF버전 두가지버전으로 덤프를 제공해드립니다.PDF버전은 구매사이트에서 무료샘플을 다움받아 체험가능합니다. 소프트웨어버전은실력테스트용으로 PDF버전공부후 보조용으로 사용가능합니다. Huawei 인증H11-861_V3.0덤프 무료샘플을 다운받아 체험해보세요.
Can’t resist liking this great content. Free Latest Principles-of-Management exam dumps sheet shared to elevate your IT skills. Wishing you success in your exams!
Your article is truly outstanding, thank you for sharing it with us! The Certification FCP_FMG_AD-7.4 torrent exam helped me climb the career ladder and increase my salary, and today, I’m offering it to you for free!
No delay, just liking this awesome content. The HPE0-V28 new exam camp materials resources are available for free—good luck, everyone!
I’m truly grateful for your article, it really made an impression. C_THR97_2405 valid real exam test questions available for free. Wishing you success in your exam!
It was such a valuable learning experience. Free D-DS-OP-23 latest test answers materials available for all—good luck!
This article is so powerful, thank you for the inspiration! The Reliable test JN0-1103 dumps pdf questions are now free! Wishing you success in your exams!
C-S4FCF-2023スタディガイドは、多くのメリットと機能を高めます。購入前にC-S4FCF-2023テスト問題をダウンロードして自由に試すことができます。当社製品を購入した後、すぐに当社製品を使用できます。選択できる3つのバージョンが用意されており、C-S4FCF-2023トレーニング資料を学習して試験を準備するのに20〜30時間しかかかりません。SAP合格率とヒット率は両方とも高いです。 1年以内に24時間のオンラインカスタマーサービスと無料アップデートを提供しています。そして、C-S4FCF-2023試験問題を試してみると、C-S4FCF-2023トレーニング資料には多くの利点があることがわかります。
Thank you for your article, it was a real revelation to me. Here’s the 1Z0-1124-24 Mock Exams test I took to earn my promotion and raise, now free for you today. Best of luck in your professional journey!
I find this article to be so motivating, thanks for sharing! Get free access to 1z0-1109-24 key concepts exam questions—good luck to everyone!
Your article is spellbinding, thank you for sharing such brilliance! Here’s the JN0-214 Cert Exam test that contributed to my career advancement and salary raise. It’s open to everyone today at no cost. May you reach your career goals soon!
Truly a brilliant article, I’m so appreciative of your sharing. Hope I can conquer the New APP RhMSUS simulations exam. Wish me luck!
That article was a real treasure trove of knowledge. Improve your IT abilities—free New NSE6_FSW-7.2 exam questions fee now available! Good luck!
I appreciate your article, it really gave me a new perspective. Thanks to the Valid test C_S4EWM_2023 test, I achieved a promotion and salary boost. Now it’s free for all. Best wishes in reaching your career goals!
Thank you for sharing this inspiring piece of writing! Here’s a free share of Flexible CFCS learning mode exam resources—good luck to you all!
Thank you for bringing such an extraordinary article! With CFE latest exam vce free, you get comprehensive material available for free to support you.
Your article is breathtaking, I really appreciate you sharing it! D-ISM-FN-23 test sample questions offers valuable resources, made available to you free of charge.
I’m thankful for your article, it was really enlightening and fresh. Free New FCP_ZCS_AD-7.4 test dumps demo exam resources are available now—good luck!
It’s truly astonishing, thank you for the share! The Latest NS0-521 learning material exam questions are free—take the first step towards career advancement and salary growth!