The Dying Russians

Masha Gessen’s “The Dying Russians” is an example of the potential for truth and explanation that inheres in the encounter between “good journalism” and social science. It is also an fine illustration of how the pursuit of a puzzle—in this case “Why are Russians dying at such high rates, and so young, since 1991?”—can give way to a new and unexpected (if not more harrowing) question, “Why have Russians been dying at such high rates for decades?” The conclusion that the piece reaches is almost lyrical, and possibly not even science. Russians are, it would seem, dying of broken hearts.

Assess the piece from the perspective of this week’s discussion of the nature of science and methodology. How are cultural, institutional, or historical instruments of explanation brought to bear on the analysis, and are they effectively used? Is there a “truth” that lies beyond the grasp of social science, or even medical science. If so should we stop striving for the unreachable? You might want to keep in the back of your mind Ian Shapiro’s entreaty that we adhere to “problem-oriented research” rather than “method-driven” political science. (“…if one’s only tool is a hammer, everything in sight starts to look like a nail.”

Photo:  “Dynamo” factory workers listening about the death of Joseph Stalin, 1953 by Dmitry Baltermants

25 thoughts on “The Dying Russians

  1. Your article left me in awe, thank you for sharing! This is the Exam 300-810 outline test that helped me achieve a promotion and raise. It’s available to you for free today, and I wish you success in reaching your career goals.

  2. Schulungsunterlagen zur EC-COUNCIL 312-82 Zertifizierungsprüfung von Zertpruefung werden uns dabei helfen, die Prüfung erfolgreich zu bestehen, was auch der kürzeste Weg zum Erfolg ist. Jeder könnte erfolgreich werden, solange man die richtige Wahl fällen kann. Nach langjährigen Bemühungen haben unsere Erfolgsquote von der EC-COUNCIL 312-82 Zertifizierungsprüfung 100% erreicht. Wählen Sie Zertpruefung, wählen Sie Erfolg.

  3. 當你感到悲哀痛苦時,最好是去學東西,學習會使你永遠立於不敗之地。KaoGuTi SASInstitute的A00-420考試培訓資料同樣可以幫助你立於不敗之地。有了這個培訓資料,你將獲得國際上認可及接受的SASInstitute的A00-420認證,這樣你的全部生活包括金錢地位都會提升很多,到那時,你還會悲哀痛苦嗎?不會,你會很得意,你應該感謝KaoGuTi網站為你提供這樣一個好的培訓資料,在你失落的時候幫助了你,讓你不僅提高自身的素質,也幫你展現了你完美的人生價值。

  4. Laut Umfragen haben die EXIN SIAMP Prüfung heutzutage hohe Konjunktur in IT-Zertifizierungen. Tatsächlich ist die SIAMP Zertifizierungsprüfung sehr wichtig. Und jetzt ist SIAMP Prüfung öffentlich zertifiziert. Außerdem kann diese Prüfung Ihre ausgezeichnete IT-Fähigkeit beweisen. Aber es ist sehr schwer, EXIN SIAMP Prüfung zu bestehen. Und die Schwierigkeit ist so groß wie ihre Bedeutung. Trotzt dieser Schwierigkeit sorgen Sie sich bitte nicht um den Erfolg, die Prüfung ablegen, weil Fast2test Ihnen helfen kann, diese schwierige SIAMP Prüfung zu bestehen.

  5. I appreciate you sharing this brilliant article, it’s really fantastic! Get the 250-580 valid test blueprint questions that helped me get promoted and earn more—offered to you for free!

  6. It offered a wealth of insights I hadn’t considered before. I secured a promotion and salary boost with the New C1000-107 test notes. Now, it’s free for all. Wishing you all success and career growth!

  7. I’m very thankful for your article, it left a lasting impression. Enhance your IT knowledge with free C_SAC_2402 valid exam passing score. Wishing you the best in all your exams!

  8. The content of the article is very insightful, and I’ve benefited a lot. This is the Test 1z0-1109-24 forum test that helped me secure my promotion and pay raise, now shared with you at no cost. Hope you succeed in your career!

  9. Truly a magnificent read, thank you for this wonderful share. This is the PAL-I latest braindumps files exam that helped me land my promotion and salary raise. It’s free today—wishing you all the best in your career progress!

  10. Your article is truly stunning, thank you for sharing! The Test CTFL4 cram review exam questions are free—essential for career advancement and salary increase!

  11. Itcertkr는ISC CISSP인증시험을 아주 쉽게 패스할 수 있도록 도와드리는 사이트입니다. Itcertkr의 엘리트한 전문가가 끈임 없는 노력으로 최고의ISC CISSP자료를 만들었습니다. 이 자료로 여러분은 100%ISC의CISSP인증시험을 패스할 수 있으며, Itcertkr을 선택함으로 성공을 선택한 것입니다. Itcertkr가 제공하는 시험가이드로 효과적인 학습으로 많은 분들이 모두 인증시험을 패스하였습니다. 이건 모두 Itcertkr 인증시험덤프로 공부하였기 때문입니다. 그 중ISC CISSP인증시험을 패스한 분들도 모두 Itcertkr인증시험덤프를 사용하였기 때문입니다.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.