My Second Reading of Masha Gessen

Posted on by

This is the second time I’ve read “The Dying Russians” for a class at Williams. The first time was last semester in a course on Russian politics. While I didn’t think it was perfect, I was overall convinced by her argument. However, on this reading, I cannot say the same. When examining her methodology, it becomes difficult to defend any of her conclusions. She attempts to use a historical approach to strengthen her cultural explanation for the crisis. While this would normally be a sound strategy, she takes a lot of liberalities in her analysis of the historical evidence. For example, she writes, “Yes, Russians have lived through severe economic upheaval, but there are is no indication that economic shock in a modern society leads quickly, or at all, to increased mortality – the Great Depression, for example, did not.” This quote seems to completely discount the utter chaos Russia underwent after the collapse of the Soviet Union. Earlier in the article, she does mention the horrors of shock therapy. However, she downplays the fact that many Russians completely lost their health care benefits as their country transitioned from communism to capitalism. In addition, the Russian state suffered a complete breakdown as citizens were forced to rely on organized crime syndicates for protection, rather than the police. This led to a massive increase in the murder rate. I think Gessen is onto something with her cultural explanation for Russian birthrates but her article is weakened by her selective reading of Russian history. Scientific studies must present all evidence.

28 thoughts on “My Second Reading of Masha Gessen”

  3. HashiCorp인증 TA-003-P시험이 너무 어려워 보여서 오르지못할 산처럼 보이시나요? 그건ExamPassdump의 HashiCorp인증 TA-003-P시험문제에 대비하여 제작한HashiCorp인증 TA-003-P덤프가 있다는 것을 모르고 있기때문입니다. HashiCorp인증 TA-003-P시험에 도전하고 싶으시다면 최강 시험패스율로 유명한ExamPassdump의 HashiCorp인증 TA-003-P덤프로 시험공부를 해보세요.시간절약은 물론이고 가격도 착해서 간단한 시험패스에 딱 좋은 선택입니다.

  4. This is a truly extraordinary piece of work, thank you for sharing. The detailed content in 300-615 valid exam cram materials is free and available to help in your academic journey.

  5. 빨리 Itexamdump 덤프를 장바구니에 넣으시죠. 그러면 100프로 자신감으로 응시하셔서 한번에 안전하게 패스하실 수 있습니다. 단 한번으로Scrum PSPO-II인증시험을 패스한다…… 여러분은 절대 후회할 일 없습니다.

  6. 我々は一番安全的な支払い方式をしようしています。弊社のC_ARCON_2404問題集を購入するなら、Paypalで支払います。Paypalは少数の手続きの費用かかる必要がありますとはいえ、保障があります。だから、弊社のC_ARCON_2404問題集をご購入になりたいお客様は心配しないで商品をご購入ください。

  7. C_THR89_2405問題集はオンライン版、ソフト版、とPDF版がありますので、とても便利です。C_THR89_2405問題集を購入すれば、あなたはいつでもどこでも勉強することができます。C_THR89_2405問題集はIT専門家が長年の研究したことです。従って、高品質で、C_THR89_2405試験の合格率が高いです。毎年、たくさんの人がC_THR89_2405試験に参加し、合格しました。あなたはC_THR89_2405問題集を利用すれば、C_THR89_2405試験に合格できますよ。もし、将来に、IT専門家になります。

  8. After reading this article, my understanding of the field has become more comprehensive. With the help of this Certification FCSS_SOC_AN-7.4 book torrent, I earned a promotion and salary increase. Now I’m offering it for free. Wishing you all the best in your career!

  13. Thank you for sharing such a powerful article, it really left an impression. This is the C-LCNC-2406 Examcollection free dumps exam I took for my promotion and salary increase. It’s free for you today—wishing you all success in your careers!

  15. Juniper인증 JN0-664시험을 패스하여 자격증을 취득하여 승진이나 이직을 꿈구고 있는 분이신가요? 이 글을 읽게 된다면Juniper인증 JN0-664시험패스를 위해 공부자료를 마련하고 싶은 마음이 크다는것을 알고 있어 시장에서 가장 저렴하고 가장 최신버전의 Juniper인증 JN0-664덤프자료를 강추해드립니다. 높은 시험패스율을 자랑하고 있는Juniper인증 JN0-664덤프는 여러분이 승진으로 향해 달리는 길에 날개를 펼쳐드립니다.자격증을 하루 빨리 취득하여 승진꿈을 이루세요.

  18. Can’t stop myself from liking this amazing content. Thanks to the TDS-C01 latest test cost, I got promoted and received a raise. Now, it’s available for free. Wishing you all success in your career!

  23. Sie können im Internet die Demo zur SAP C_THR87_2405 Zertifizierungsprüfung von Fast2test vorm Kauf als Probe kostenlos herunterladen, so dass Sie unsere Produkte ohne Risiko kaufen. Sie werden die Qualität unserer Produkte und die Freundlichkeit unserer Website sehen. Außerdem bieten wir Ihnen einen einjährigen kostenlosen Update-Service. Sonst erstatten wir Ihnen die gesammte Summe zurück, um die Interessen der Kunden zu schützen. Die Schulungsunterlagen zur SAP C_THR87_2405 Zertifizierungsprüfung von Fast2test ist anwendbar. Sie werden Ihnen sicher passen und einen guten Effekt erzielen. Sie werden sicher etwas Unerwartetes bekommen.

  25. Amazing content, I’m on board, liking it now. The Reliable CRISC test questions helped me climb the career ladder and earn a raise. Now, I’m sharing it for free with all of you. Wishing you success!

  27. You offer a very interesting critique of Gessen’s argument. I think the fact that Gessen uses both historical and cultural lenses simultaneously is important to parse. I think that you make a good point that comparing the Russian economic upheaval with the Great Depression in the United States is not a fair analysis. Not only were the events different, but comparing a capitalist downturn in American society with a complete economic reconstruction in the Russian society is, as we said in class, comparing apples and oranges. One would have to break down the cultural dissimilarities between the United States and Russia completely to even begin to compare the historical events. I think by using cultural and historical analyses without addressing each separately weakens Gessen’s argument.

  28. I agree that Gessen seems to cherry-pick the facts she uses to present her claim. She does indeed seem to ignore certain aspects of Russian history, if not totally negate them.

    Interestingly, she also seems to alternate her idea of sufficient evidence throughout the paper. For example, in the quote you provide, Gessen says that because there is no established link between economic upheaval and an increase in mortality rates the latter cannot be the cause of the former in Russia’s case. However, she then totally contradicts this when sharing her final conclusion, as she claims that Russians are dying from a loss of hope ( a dubious claim to start out with ) despite little evidence actually suggesting there is a link. It is this kind of change in position that harms the general credibility of her paper.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.