A hollow democracy

In an essential sense, Evergreen’s classroom exhibits all the hallmarks of an electoral democracy. There is competition between the candidates, the candidates are responsive to the student “citizens”, and citizen’s votes directly determine the outcome of the election. However, watching the whole process play out elucidates the many ways in which a system that looks like a democracy from the outside may not be effective on the inside.

The voters seem poorly prepared in their understanding of what it means to “vote” and, although their teacher tries to explain the concept, they are still convinced by bribery to vote for Luo Lei, whose leadership style they clearly dislike. The social and economic standing of the children’s parents, their “political action committees” one might say, has a disproportionate effect on the children’s success in their tasks, and ultimately the most wealthy student prevails. Although it is unclear, Luo Lei is clearly threatening to the children, a factor that might also force them to vote in a biased manner. Finally, the reelection of a “dictator-like” leader, Luo Lei, makes us question whether the institution of democracy does indeed open society and the polity, as Karl and Schmitter propose, since we do not actually know if Luo Lei would have peacefully relinquished power. In certain ways, visible only through the close lens of the documentary, Evergreen school’s electoral democracy fits many of our positive definitions of democracy, while exhibiting significant normative issues in practice.

21 thoughts on “A hollow democracy

  1. Wir Fast2test bietet Ihnen die Prüfungsfragen und Antworten zur Scrum SAFe-SASM von höchster Qualität, damit Sie viel näher von Ihrem Erfolg sind. Wenn Sie noch ein paar Sorgen haben, können Sie die SAFe-SASM Demo durch die Webseite Fast2test herunterladen. Hier versprechen wir Ihnen, dass wir Ihnen noch einjähriger Aktualisierung kostenlos anbieten werden, nachdem Sie die Prüfungsfragen und Antworten zur Scrum SAFe-SASM gekauft haben.

  2. Your article truly made me think, thank you for the fresh viewpoint. This is the Latest study guide GB0-392 pdf exam that helped me land my promotion and salary raise. It’s free today—wishing you all the best in your career progress!

  3. What a brilliant article, I’m so grateful for your generosity. I achieved career success with the C-TS414-2023 reliable test study guide, earning both a promotion and raise. It’s free for everyone now. Best of luck!

  4. It’s truly amazing, thank you for the fantastic share! This C-SIGDA-2403 latest test bootcamp helped me climb the career ladder and secure a raise. Now, it’s free for everyone. Wishing you all success in your careers!

  5. 為通過Salesforce ANC-201 認證考試花大量的時間和精力復習相關知識,但是卻是冒險地通過考試。選擇Testpdf的產品卻可以讓你花少量的錢,一次性安全通過考試。我相信在如今時間如此寶貴的社會裏,Testpdf更適合你的選擇。而且我們的Testpdf是眾多類似網站中最能給你保障的一個網站,選擇Testpdf就等於選擇了成功。

  6. I’m left in complete awe by your article, thank you for sharing it! I used the NS0-700 exam simulator fee to get promoted and enjoy a salary raise. Now it’s free for everyone. Wishing you all a smooth promotion journey!

  7. Die Produkte von Pass4Test wird Ihnen nicht nur helfen, die SAP C_TS4CO_2023-German Zertifizierungsprüfung erfolgreich zu bestehen, sondern auch Ihnen einen einjährigen kostenlosen Update-Service bieten. Wir werden den Kunden die neuesten von uns entwickelten Produkte in der ersten Zeit liefern, so dass Sie sich gut auf die SAP C_TS4CO_2023-German Prüfung vorbereiten können. Falls Sie in der SAP C_TS4CO_2023-German Prüfung durchfallen, zahlen wir Ihnen dann die gesammte Summe zurück.

  8. I completely agree. While it is obvious that democracy fails if citizens fail to actually participate, “Please Vote for Me” shows us that democracy can fail even with participation. While in theory democracy gives each citizen a voice, it is clear that oftentimes democracy succumbs to things like hatred, bribery, and ignorance. While most would look in on this third grade classroom from the outside and immediately notice the problems at hand, many fail to realize that what was shown on screen is not unique, and is increasingly common in democracies everywhere.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.